Handy Home Products Braymore 10x14 Do-It-Yourself Wooden vs Handy Home Products Astoria 12x12 Do-It-Yourself Wooden: Spec Comparison
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comparison looks at the handy home products braymore 10x14 do it yourself wooden vs astoria models. Both sheds are wooden structures with 7-foot side walls and extra-large doors. They share a brown color and require separate floor kits, paint, and shingles. The main difference lies in their footprint and roof design. The Astoria offers a square 12x12 layout with a standard peak. The Braymore provides a rectangular 10x14 space with a taller gambrel roof. You need to decide which shape fits your yard best.
Key differences
| Aspect | Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed | Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Footprint Size | 12x12 ft | 10x14 ft |
| Peak Height | 9 ft 11 in | 11 ft 5 in |
| Roof Style | Standard peak | Gambrel roof |
| Overall Height | 119 inches | 134 inches |
| Weight | 1500 pounds | 1700 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed if
- You need a square footprint that fits neatly into a corner.
- You prefer a lower overall height of 119 inches.
- You want a lighter structure at 1500 pounds.
Choose Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed if
- You require a rectangular layout with a 14-foot length.
- You need maximum vertical clearance with a 134-inch peak.
- You want a traditional barn style with a gambrel roof.
Verdict: The Astoria is the better choice if you need a compact, square footprint that is easier to position in tight spaces. The Braymore suits you better if you prioritize tall vertical storage and a longer rectangular shape. Both models offer the same 7-foot side walls and door width for practical access.
Size and Height Comparison
Footprint dimensions
The Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed offers a 12-foot by 12-foot footprint, giving you a total of 144 square feet of floor space. The Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed provides a 10-foot by 14-foot layout, also totaling 144 square feet. Both sheds provide the same amount of ground-level storage area. You can arrange your tools and equipment differently depending on which shape fits your yard better. The Astoria is more square, while the Braymore is more rectangular. Neither shed includes a floor kit, so you will need to build your own foundation regardless of the shape you choose.
Peak height
Vertical storage is a key factor for many buyers. The Astoria 12x12 reaches a peak height of 9 feet 11 inches, with 7-foot side walls. The Braymore 10x14 features a gambrel roof that allows for a taller peak of 11 feet 5 inches, also with 7-foot side walls. The Braymore gives you an extra 1 foot 8 inches of height at the center. This additional vertical space is useful for storing taller items like ladders or long-handled rakes. If you need maximum overhead clearance, the Braymore design provides more room at the peak.
Overall weight
Weight indicates the amount of material used in construction. The Astoria 12x12 weighs 1500 pounds. The Braymore 10x14 weighs 1700 pounds. The Braymore is 200 pounds heavier. This difference likely comes from the gambrel roof structure and the longer 14-foot sides compared to the 12-foot sides of the Astoria. A heavier shed may feel more substantial and stable in wind, but it also requires a stronger foundation to support the load. You will need to ensure your ground preparation can handle the extra weight of the Braymore.
Roof style
The roof design affects both aesthetics and interior volume. The Astoria 12x12 uses a standard roof style that results in its 9-foot 11-inch peak. The Braymore 10x14 features a traditional barn-style gambrel roof. This shape allows for the taller 11-foot 5-inch peak despite having a narrower width. The gambrel roof provides more usable space near the walls at higher levels. If you prefer a classic barn look or want more accessible upper storage, the Braymore’s roof style is the better choice. The Astoria offers a simpler, more conventional profile.
Frame construction
Both sheds use premium 2x4 wood framing for ground-to-peak strength. This common feature ensures durability and stability in both models. The Astoria 12x12 uses this framing across its 12x12 footprint. The Braymore 10x14 uses the same 2x4 framing across its 10x14 footprint. Since both utilize identical framing materials and methods, there is no difference in the core structural integrity provided by the wood itself. You can expect similar load-bearing capabilities from the walls and roof supports in both sheds, assuming proper assembly and foundation.
Door width
Access to your storage area is important for moving large items. Both the Astoria 12x12 and the Braymore 10x14 feature extra-large doors that are 5 feet 4 inches wide. Both doors also include continuous galvanized steel hinges for durability. This consistent door width means you will have the same ease of entry and exit for both sheds. Large equipment like wheelbarrows or lawnmowers can fit through either door without issue. The door specification does not differentiate these two models, as both provide ample access for typical garden and storage needs.
Choose the right shed for your space
You need maximum square footage for large items
The Astoria 12x12 model provides a 144-square-foot footprint. Its 12-foot by 12-inch layout offers a wide, open floor plan. This shape is ideal for storing wide equipment like lawnmowers or garden tractors. The 12x12 dimensions allow you to organize tools along the perimeter without crowding the center area. You get consistent width and depth for easier planning.
You prefer a taller peak for vertical storage
The Braymore 10x14 model features a 11-foot 5-inch peak height. This is taller than the Astoria's 9-foot 11-inch peak. The Gambrel roof design creates more usable vertical space near the walls. You can store taller items like long ladders or rakes more easily. The extra height allows for better airflow and easier access to upper shelves.
You want a narrower footprint for tight yards
The Braymore 10x14 shed has a 10-foot width. This is narrower than the Astoria's 12-foot width. If you have limited side clearance, the 10-foot width fits better in tighter spaces. The 14-foot length still provides ample storage depth. This configuration is practical for narrow backyards or side yard placements where width is the primary constraint.
The products compared
Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed
Best for: storing tall ladders and garden tools
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12x12 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing
- Roof Style
- 9 ft 11 in peak height
- Features
- 7 ft tall side walls
- Recommended Use
- Ladders, rakes, shovels
View on Amazon: Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Astoria 12x12 shed offers a 144-square-foot footprint for substantial storage. Its 7-foot side walls and 9-foot 11-inch peak height accommodate tall items like ladders and rakes. The 2x4 wood framing provides structural strength. You get extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors for easy access. Note that the floor kit is not included, requiring a custom foundation.
Pros
- 12x12 foot footprint provides ample storage space
- 7-foot tall side walls suit vertical storage needs
- 2x4 wood framing ensures ground-to-peak strength
- Extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors allow easy access
Cons
- Floor kit is not included
- Paint and shingles are sold separately
- Heavy weight requires careful handling
Good fit if
- You need a large 12x12 footprint for bulky items
- You want tall walls for vertical storage of long tools
- You plan to build a custom foundation like a cement pad
Skip if
- You want a shed with a pre-installed floor
- You prefer a smaller 10x14 footprint
- You need a fully painted and shingled unit out of the box
Verdict: Handy Home Products Astoria 12x12 Wooden Shed fits users needing maximum interior height and a large 12x12 footprint for storing tall equipment. It is ideal if you are prepared to install your own floor and finish the exterior yourself.
Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed
Best for: vertical storage of long gardening tools
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10x14 ft
- Roof Style
- Gambrel roof, 11 ft 5 in peak height
- Features
- 7 ft tall side walls
- Recommended Use
- Ladders, rakes, shovels
- Color
- Brown
View on Amazon: Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Braymore is a 10x14 ft wooden storage shed with a traditional gambrel roof. It stands 7 ft tall at the sides and reaches an 11 ft 5 in peak height. The 5 ft 4 in wide doors feature continuous galvanized steel hinges. You get a large footprint for vertical storage of ladders and tools. Note that the floor kit is not included in this package.
Pros
- 10x14 ft footprint offers ample storage space
- 11 ft 5 in peak height for tall items
- 5 ft 4 in wide doors with steel hinges
- Wood construction with traditional barn style
Cons
- Floor kit is not included
- Paint and shingles are sold separately
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
Good fit if
- You need vertical storage for long tools like ladders
- You plan to build a custom foundation
- You want a traditional wooden shed style
Skip if
- You require a pre-installed floor
- You live in Florida
- You want a fully finished exterior without extra purchases
Verdict: The Handy Home Products Braymore 10x14 Wooden Shed suits you if you need tall vertical storage and are ready to add your own floor and finish. It is not the right fit if you want a complete package with a floor included.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed | Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Wood | Wood |
| Footprint Size | 12x12 ft | 10x14 ft |
| Frame Material | 2x4 wood framing | not stated |
| Roof Style | 9 ft 11 in peak height | Gambrel roof, 11 ft 5 in peak height |
| Features | 7 ft tall side walls | 7 ft tall side walls |
| Recommended Use | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Ladders, rakes, shovels |
| Color | Brown | Brown |
| Dimensions | 147 × 157 × 119 inches | 171 × 122 × 134 inches |
| Weight | 1500 pounds | 1700 pounds |
| Size | 12x12 | 10x14 |
| Model | 19413-9 | 19454-2 |
Frequently asked questions
Which shed is taller for storing tall items?
The Handy Home Braymore 10x14 is taller. It reaches 134 inches in height, which is 15 inches more than the Astoria model. This extra vertical space makes it better for storing tall ladders or long garden tools. The Astoria 12x12 stands at 119 inches high.
Does either shed come with a floor included?
No, neither shed includes a floor. Both the Astoria 12x12 and the Braymore 10x14 require you to install your own floor separately. You will need to purchase a floor kit and finish the exterior yourself before placing the structure on it.
How much heavier is the Braymore compared to the Astoria?
The Braymore 10x14 weighs 200 pounds more than the Astoria. The Braymore tips the scale at 1700 pounds, while the Astoria weighs 1500 pounds. This difference may affect how you plan for delivery and the strength of your foundation.
What is the difference in width between the two sheds?
The Astoria 12x12 is wider than the Braymore 10x14. The Astoria measures 157 inches wide, while the Braymore is 122 inches wide. This makes the Astoria a better choice if you need a wider opening or more side-to-side storage space.
Which model has a longer footprint?
The Braymore 10x14 has a longer footprint. It measures 171 inches in length, whereas the Astoria 12x12 is 147 inches long. If you need extra length for long equipment, the Braymore provides that additional linear space.
Are both sheds made of the same material?
Yes, both sheds are made of wood. They share the same brown color and wooden construction. The primary differences lie in their dimensions and weight rather than the base material used for their frames and siding.