Looking Beyond the Handy Home Products Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Looking for handy home products handy home scarsdale 12x16 alternatives? This guide compares seven other wooden storage sheds that share similar specifications. The original Scarsdale model offers a substantial 12x16 footprint with an included floor kit. It stands 126 inches tall and weighs nearly 1,929 pounds. You get unfinished wood siding that requires your own paint and assembly effort. This large, DIY-friendly structure suits buyers who need maximum interior space and are willing to do the work.
You might want different specs for your yard. Some buyers prefer a smaller footprint or a different height. Others may prioritize pre-finished siding or specific window placements for natural light. The alternatives listed here overlap with the Scarsdale in key areas like material type and floor inclusion. Each option presents a distinct trade-off in size, weight, or design features. You can compare these 6 models to find a shed that fits your exact storage needs and assembly preferences.
Our top pick: Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit.
How other sheds compare
Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed
The Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed offers a slightly smaller footprint at 12 by 14 feet, reducing interior square footage compared to the 12x16 Scarsdale. It stands shorter at 107 inches versus 126 inches, which may limit storage for very tall items. This model weighs less at 1,421 pounds, making it somewhat easier to handle during assembly. It includes windows for natural light, a feature absent in the Scarsdale. The siding comes in brown, so you still need to paint or stain it. Choose this if you prefer a dedicated workshop space with better visibility and do not need the maximum height of the Scarsdale.
Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor
The Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor is narrower at 10 feet wide, saving yard space while maintaining a 16-foot length. It is shorter at 114 inches, which reduces vertical storage capacity compared to the Scarsdale. This unit weighs 1,521 pounds, making it lighter than the 1,929-pound Scarsdale. It comes pre-colored in brown, eliminating the need for painting that the unfinished Scarsdale requires. The included floor kit provides the same sturdy base. Pick this alternative if your yard is narrower and you want a ready-to-use color without the extra weight and height of the larger model.
Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor
The Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor shares the 10-foot width and 16-foot length of the Rookwood, but it stands taller at 134 inches. This extra height offers more vertical storage than the Scarsdale, which is only 126 inches tall. It weighs less than the Scarsdale, though exact weight is not listed. Like the Rookwood, it comes in brown, saving you the step of painting. The included floor kit matches the Scarsdale. Select this shed if you need to store tall gardening tools or equipment that exceeds the height of the Scarsdale, while still appreciating the pre-finished exterior color.
Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer
The Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer is significantly smaller, with a 12 by 10 foot footprint compared to the 12x16 Scarsdale. It matches the Scarsdale height at 120 inches, though the Scarsdale is 126 inches. This unit weighs 1,600 pounds, making it lighter. It includes windows and a dormer for natural light, features the Scarsdale lacks. The unpainted wood requires your finishing work. Choose this option if you have limited yard space and prefer a smaller storage unit with aesthetic details like a dormer and windows, rather than the expansive floor area of the Scarsdale.
ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit
The ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit is square, measuring 12 by 12 feet, which reduces total floor space compared to the Scarsdale. It stands taller at 137 inches, offering more vertical clearance than the Scarsdale. This model weighs less, though the exact figure is not provided. It includes a floor kit and comes unpainted, requiring you to finish the wood. The design prioritizes wide door access, which may facilitate moving larger equipment in and out. Pick this shed if you prefer a compact square layout with extra height and do not need the elongated 16-foot length of the Scarsdale.
ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
The ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit is narrower at 10 feet wide but matches the 16-foot length of the Scarsdale. It is shorter at 99 inches, which limits tall storage options compared to the 126-inch Scarsdale. This unit weighs 1,481 pounds, making it lighter to assemble. It comes unpainted, so you must apply your own finish. The included floor kit provides a solid base. Choose this alternative if you want a long shed for wide equipment access but can accept a lower roof height and narrower width, resulting in a lighter overall structure.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: large DIY wooden storage with a floor
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12 x 16 ft
- Assembly
- Do-it-yourself kit
- Features
- Floor kit included
- Dimensions
- 209 × 160 × 126 inches
- Weight
- 1929 pounds
View on Amazon: Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Scarsdale is a 12x16 ft do-it-yourself wooden storage shed. It measures 160 inches wide and 209 inches long, with a height of 126 inches. The kit includes a floor, making it ready for immediate use. Weighing 1,929 pounds, it offers substantial storage capacity. This unfinished wood structure suits buyers who want a large, permanent base for tools or equipment without extra floor installation.
Pros
- Includes a floor kit for immediate ground-level storage
- Large 12x16 ft footprint provides ample space
- Constructed from durable unfinished wood
- Solid 1,929-pound weight ensures stability
Cons
- Requires DIY assembly and painting
- Heavy at 1,929 pounds, complicating transport
- Unfinished wood needs protection from elements
Good fit if
- You need a large, permanent storage footprint
- You want a floor included in the kit
- You are prepared to assemble and finish the wood
Skip if
- You prefer a pre-painted, ready-to-use structure
- You lack the help to handle a 1,929-pound kit
- You want a smaller 10x16 ft option
Verdict: Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed fits buyers who need a large, floor-included wooden base and have the labor to assemble and finish it. It is not for those seeking a quick, pre-finished setup.
Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed
Best for: durable workshop with a built-in floor
- Material
- LP SmartSide siding, primed
- Footprint Size
- 12 x 14 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls
- Assembly
- Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware
- Recommended Use
- Tools, lawn equipment, large items
- Features
- Floor, Windows
View on Amazon: Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed Affiliate link
This 12x14 wood shed offers 168 square feet of interior space with 6-foot sidewalls and 2x4 framing rated for heavy snow. It includes a treated wood floor and operable windows for natural light. The LP SmartSide siding is primed for painting. You get large 60x72-inch double doors for easy access. This kit suits those needing a durable workshop or storage area with a finished floor.
Pros
- 168 sq. ft. interior with 6 ft. sidewalls
- 2x4 framing rated for high winds and snow
- Includes treated 2x4 floor with 5/8 in. OSB
- LP SmartSide siding primed for painting
- Large 60 in. W x 72 in. H double doors
Cons
- 12x14 footprint is smaller than the 12x16 competitors
- Siding requires you to purchase and apply paint
- Shingles and drip edge are not included
Good fit if
- You need a sturdy workshop with a built-in floor
- You want primed siding to match your home's exterior
- You prefer natural light from operable windows
Skip if
- You require the maximum 12x16 footprint size
- You want a fully finished shed without extra purchases
- You prefer vinyl siding that needs no painting
Verdict: Little Cottage 12x14 Value Workshop provides a robust 168 sq. ft. workspace with a solid floor and snow-rated framing. It fits buyers who want a customizable, durable structure and do not mind painting the siding themselves.
Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor
Best for: Tall tool storage in narrow yards
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10x16 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood frame
- Assembly
- Do-It-Yourself, includes floor kit
- Roof Style
- 9'-6" peak height
- Interior Dimensions
- 134 in W x 193 in L x 114 in H
View on Amazon: Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Rookwood 10x16 is a do-it-yourself wooden storage shed designed for vertical organization. It features 7-foot side walls and a 9-foot-6-inch peak height to accommodate tall items like ladders and rakes. The unit includes a complete floor system with a 2x4 wood frame and 5/8-inch OSB decking. You get extra-large doors that are 5 feet 4 inches wide, making access easier for bulky gear.
Pros
- 7-foot side walls and 9-foot-6-inch peak height for vertical storage
- Includes complete floor system with 2x4 frame and 5/8-inch OSB decking
- Extra-large 5-foot-4-inch wide doors with continuous galvanized steel hinges
- Do-it-yourself assembly with floor kit included
Cons
- Smaller footprint than the 12x16 models on this list
- Requires separate purchase of paint and shingles
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
Good fit if
- You need tall vertical space for long tools and ladders
- You want a pre-built floor system included in the kit
- You prefer a narrower shed that fits in tighter side yards
Skip if
- You require a 12-foot width for wider equipment storage
- You live in Florida where this model is not sold
- You want a fully painted and shingled shed ready for use
Verdict: The Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed offers ample height and a sturdy floor for users who prioritize vertical storage and easy access over maximum floor width.
Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor
Best for: vertical storage of tall gardening tools
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10x16 ft
- Frame Material
- Wood framing
- Assembly
- Do-It-Yourself, includes floor kit
- Roof Style
- 11'-5" peak height
- Interior Dimensions
- 122 in W x 195 in L x 134 in H
View on Amazon: Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Affiliate link
The Handy Home Braymore 10x16 offers a spacious 122 by 195 inch interior with 134 inch peak height. It includes a complete wood floor with framing and OSB decking. The 7-foot side walls support vertical storage for tall tools. You can choose door placement and trim. Note that it is not available in Florida due to weather restrictions.
Pros
- Includes complete wood floor kit with framing and OSB decking
- 134 inch peak height accommodates tall items like ladders
- Extra-large 5' 4" doors with continuous galvanized steel hinges
- Flexible design allows customization of door location and trim
Cons
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
- Requires DIY assembly and separate purchase of paint and shingles
- Smaller footprint than the 12x16 or 12x14 options on this list
Good fit if
- You need extra height for ladders or long-handled tools
- You want a pre-built floor to skip sub-base work
- You prefer a wooden structure with customizable exterior details
Skip if
- You live in Florida where this model is restricted
- You need a larger 12x16 or 12x14 footprint
- You want a fully assembled shed with included paint
Verdict: The Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed fits buyers who prioritize vertical storage and a ready-to-use floor over maximum square footage. It is a practical option for those willing to handle DIY assembly and painting.
Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer
Best for: smaller storage needs with natural light
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12x10 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in double doors; 32 in service door
- Frame Material
- 2x4 framing, 24 in on-center studs
- Assembly
- Pre-cut wood kit; 2 adults, 4-8 hours
- Roof Style
- Dormer
View on Amazon: Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer Affiliate link
This 12x10 wooden storage shed features a dormer roof and primed, treated siding. It includes a complete wood floor and three operational windows with screens. The structure uses 2x4 framing to withstand 115 mph winds and 23 psf snow loads. You get 64-inch double doors and a 32-inch service door. It allows for customizable placement of doors and windows.
Pros
- Includes complete wood floor with OSB decking
- Three operational windows with screens
- Primed and treated wood siding
- Wind resistance up to 115 mph
Cons
- Smaller 12x10 footprint than the 12x16 Scarsdale
- Paint and shingles sold separately
- Requires 4-8 hours to assemble
Good fit if
- You need a smaller footprint than 12x16
- You want natural light from windows
- You prefer customizable door placement
Skip if
- You need the maximum 12x16 floor space
- You want a pre-painted finished look
- You prefer a workshop with operable windows
Verdict: Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed fits buyers who want a smaller, well-framed storage unit with natural light, rather than the larger Scarsdale footprint.
ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: Wide equipment access and included flooring
- Footprint Size
- 12x12 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in. pre-hung double doors
- Frame Material
- Heavy-duty wood structure
- Features
- Floor
- Dimensions
- 147 × 146 × 137 inches
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
This 12x12 wooden storage shed offers a 146 by 147 inch footprint with a 137 inch height. It features a complete wood floor system and a storage loft for extra capacity. The 64 inch pre-hung double doors provide wide access for large equipment. The treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed, allowing you to customize the exterior finish. It is designed for DIY assembly by two adults.
Pros
- Includes a complete wood floor system
- Features a storage loft for additional capacity
- 64 inch pre-hung double doors for wide access
- Factory-primed siding ready for custom painting
Cons
- Smaller 12x12 footprint compared to 12x16 competitors
- Paint and shingles are sold separately
- Assembly requires at least two adults
Good fit if
- You need a wide entry for lawn tractors or mowers
- You want a pre-built floor to skip subfloor construction
- You prefer to customize the exterior paint color yourself
Skip if
- You require the larger 12x16 footprint found in other options
- You want a fully finished exterior without buying extra materials
- You need a smaller 10x16 or 10x12 footprint
Verdict: ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Storage Shed fits buyers who prioritize wide door access and a ready-to-use floor over maximum interior square footage. It is a solid choice for storing medium-sized equipment in a space-constrained yard.
ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: Storing large equipment with wide access
- Material
- Treated engineered wood siding
- Footprint Size
- 10 ft. x 16 ft.
- Capacity
- 1,105 cu. ft.
- Frame Material
- Wood construction
- Assembly
- Pre-cut wood kit, 2 adults, 32 hours
- Recommended Use
- Large equipment
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 offers 1,105 cubic feet of storage in a 10 ft by 16 ft footprint. It features treated engineered wood siding that is factory-primed for your paint and shingle choices. The unit includes a floor kit and 64-inch wide doors for easy equipment access. Assembly requires two adults and approximately 32 hours. This structure is designed to handle demanding wind and snow loads.
Pros
- 1,105 cubic feet of interior storage space
- 64-inch wide pre-hung doors for large equipment
- Factory-primed treated engineered wood siding
- Includes floor kit for immediate use
Cons
- Assembly takes 32 hours with intermediate skills
- Paint and roof shingles are sold separately
- Heavy at 1,481 pounds requiring two adults
Good fit if
- You need a large footprint for bulky gear
- You plan to customize the exterior finish
- You want a floor kit included
Skip if
- You prefer a quick assembly under 10 hours
- You want a finished roof and paint included
- You need a smaller 10x12 or 12x12 footprint
Verdict: ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed suits buyers who prioritize maximum interior volume and a wide door opening for large items. It is ideal for those willing to invest time in assembly and customization.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit | Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed | Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor | Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor | Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer | ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit | ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Wood | LP SmartSide siding, primed | Wood | Wood | Wood | not stated | Treated engineered wood siding |
| Footprint Size | 12 x 16 ft | 12 x 14 ft | 10x16 ft | 10x16 ft | 12x10 ft | 12x12 ft | 10 ft. x 16 ft. |
| Capacity | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | 1,105 cu. ft. |
| Door Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | 64 in double doors; 32 in service door | 64 in. pre-hung double doors | not stated |
| Frame Material | not stated | 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls | 2x4 wood frame | Wood framing | 2x4 framing, 24 in on-center studs | Heavy-duty wood structure | Wood construction |
| Assembly | Do-it-yourself kit | Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware | Do-It-Yourself, includes floor kit | Do-It-Yourself, includes floor kit | Pre-cut wood kit; 2 adults, 4-8 hours | not stated | Pre-cut wood kit, 2 adults, 32 hours |
| Roof Style | not stated | not stated | 9'-6" peak height | 11'-5" peak height | Dormer | not stated | not stated |
| Features | Floor kit included | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Interior Dimensions | not stated | not stated | 134 in W x 193 in L x 114 in H | 122 in W x 195 in L x 134 in H | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Recommended Use | not stated | Tools, lawn equipment, large items | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Customizable storage | not stated | Large equipment |
| Color | Unfinished Wood | Brown | Brown | Brown | Unpainted | Unpainted | Unpainted |
| Dimensions | 209 × 160 × 126 inches | 168 × 144 × 107 inches | 193 × 134 × 114 inches | 195 × 122 × 134 inches | 146 × 120 × 120 inches | 147 × 146 × 137 inches | 192 × 127 × 99 inches |
| Weight | 1929 pounds | 1421 pounds | 1521 pounds | not stated | 1600 pounds | not stated | 1481 pounds |
| Size | 12x16 | 12x14 | 10x16 | 10x16 | not stated | 12x12 | 10X16 |
| Model | 19527-3 | 12x14 VWS-PC-FK | 19437-5 | 19458-0 | 18026-2 | 18264-8 | 18253-2 |
Frequently asked questions
Is there a smaller Handy Home option than the Scarsdale?
Yes, the Handy Home Designer 12x10 Wood Shed with Dormer is a smaller alternative. It measures 120 inches wide and 146 inches long, offering a compact footprint compared to the 160-inch width of the Scarsdale. This model includes a floor and windows for natural light, making it suitable for tighter yards.
Which shed provides the most interior height?
The Handy Home Braymore 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor offers the greatest height at 134 inches. This vertical design prioritizes tall storage over wide floor space. It features a ready-to-use floor and brown siding, ideal for storing long gardening tools or ladders without sacrificing door clearance.
Are there wood sheds with wider door access?
The ShedMaster Fieldstone 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit is designed for wide access. It provides a 127-inch width and 192-inch length to accommodate large equipment. The unpainted wood construction allows for customization, and the included floor kit ensures a sturdy base for heavy items.
Does the Little Cottage Co. shed include a floor?
Yes, the Little Cottage Co. 12x14 Wood Workshop Shed includes a built-in floor. It measures 144 inches wide and 168 inches long, providing a robust workspace. The brown siding is unfinished, requiring you to paint it yourself, but the structure is rated for snow loads.
What is the weight of the Handy Home Rookwood?
The Handy Home Rookwood 10x16 Wood Shed with Floor weighs 1,521 pounds. This model stands 114 inches tall and measures 134 inches wide. It is a brown, unfinished wood structure that emphasizes vertical storage capacity within a narrower footprint than the larger Scarsdale model.
Is there a 12x12 wood shed with a floor?
The ShedMaster Westfield 12x12 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit fits this description. It measures 146 inches wide and 147 inches long, with a height of 137 inches. The unpainted wood construction includes an included floor, offering wide equipment access for medium-sized storage needs.