Handy Home Products vs ShedMaster Storage Sheds: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing handy home products vs ShedMaster storage shed options, you face a choice between scale and manageability. Both brands offer unfinished wooden sheds with floor kits, allowing you to customize the exterior with your own paint and shingles. The primary difference lies in size. Handy Home Products provides a compact 10x7.5 foot footprint, while ShedMaster offers a massive 24x12 foot structure. This size gap dictates everything from assembly time to storage capacity.
Key differences
| Aspect | Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit | ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Footprint Size | 10 x 7.5 ft | 24 x 12 ft |
| Dimensions | 90" W x 90" H x 64" L | 160" W x 126" H x 306" L |
| Weight | 1172 pounds | not listed |
| Frame Material | Wood framing | 2x4 construction |
| Ventilation | not listed | Arched gable vents and windows |
| Assembly Time | not listed | 32 hours |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit if
- You need a smaller footprint that fits in tighter spaces.
- You prefer a lighter structure that may be easier to handle.
- You want a shed primarily for large equipment access.
Choose ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed if
- You require maximum vertical storage with 7-foot sidewalls.
- You want natural light and airflow from built-in vents and windows.
- You have the space for a large 24x12 foot foundation.
Verdict: Choose the Handy Home Products Olympia if you need a manageable, compact storage solution for large equipment. Select the ShedMaster Brookside if you have the yard space and time for a major DIY project that offers substantial vertical storage and ventilation.
Size and Build Quality Comparison
Footprint Size
ShedMaster offers a massive 24x12 foot footprint, providing significantly more storage area than Handy Home’s 10x7.5 foot model. The larger dimensions allow for bulkier items and greater overall volume. Handy Home’s smaller size is better suited for tighter yards or smaller backyards where space is limited. You must choose based on your available ground space. The ShedMaster requires a much larger area to install. The Handy Home fits into narrower gaps. Check your yard dimensions carefully before deciding, as the size difference is substantial and impacts placement options for both sheds.
Vertical Height
ShedMaster provides 126 inches of height, which is 10.5 feet. This allows for tall items and vertical storage solutions. Handy Home stands at 90 inches, or 7.5 feet tall. While 7.5 feet is sufficient for most standard storage, the extra height in the ShedMaster lets you store taller equipment or stack items higher. The 7-foot sidewalls mentioned in the features support this vertical capacity. If you need to store tall ladders or machinery, the extra height matters. For standard bins, both heights work well. The height difference is clear and affects what you can store inside.
Door Width
Both sheds feature 64-inch wide doors, which is an extra-wide opening for easy access. This width helps you move large equipment, lawnmowers, or bulky items in and out without difficulty. Neither brand has a narrower door that would restrict access. The 64-inch width is a shared strength for both models. You do not need to worry about fitting wide items through the entrance with either option. This spec is identical for both, making it a neutral factor in your decision. It ensures convenience for loading and unloading large objects in both sheds.
Ventilation Features
ShedMaster includes arched gable vents and windows to improve natural light and air circulation. These features help manage moisture and temperature inside the shed. Handy Home’s data does not list specific vents or windows. While wood sheds often have some airflow, the explicit inclusion of vents and windows in the ShedMaster is a clear advantage for ventilation. If you store sensitive items or want better air quality, the ShedMaster’s features are beneficial. The absence of listed ventilation specs for Handy Home means you cannot assume they are present. This makes ShedMaster the better choice for airflow control.
Construction Material
Both sheds use wood construction, but the specifics differ. Handy Home uses sturdy wood framing and OSB decking for the floor. ShedMaster uses treated engineered wood siding with 2x4 construction. The treated siding in the ShedMaster offers resistance to warping and rot, which is a practical benefit for longevity. Handy Home’s wood floor kit includes framing and decking, providing a solid base. Both are unfinished and require your paint and shingles. The treated siding on the ShedMaster may offer better weather resistance out of the box. Handy Home relies on your finishing choices for protection.
Which Storage Shed Brand Fits Your Needs
Someone needing maximum storage volume
The ShedMaster Brookside offers a massive 24x12 foot footprint. This provides significantly more interior space for bulkier items compared to smaller models. Its 7-foot sidewalls create ample vertical storage room. The 64-inch wide double doors allow easy access for large equipment. You get substantial square footage for your items.
Buyer with limited backyard space
The Handy Home Olympia fits tighter areas with its 10x7.5 foot footprint. It measures 90 inches wide and 90 inches high. This smaller size is manageable for smaller yards. It still features 64-inch extra-wide doors for large equipment access. You get a sturdy wood structure without requiring a huge installation area.
User wanting natural light and airflow
ShedMaster includes arched gable vents and windows in this model. These features provide natural light and improve air circulation inside. This helps keep stored items dry and visible. The treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed for painting. You get better ventilation and visibility for your storage contents.
The products compared
Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: Storing large equipment with wide door access
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10 x 7.5 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in extra-wide doors
- Frame Material
- Wood framing
- Features
- Wood floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Large equipment
View on Amazon: Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
This Handy Home Products Olympia shed offers a 10 by 7.5 foot footprint for storing large equipment. It features sturdy wood construction with a complete wood floor kit. The 64-inch extra-wide doors provide easy access to bulky items. You get unfinished wood that you can paint or stain yourself. Note that this model is not available in Florida due to weather restrictions.
Pros
- Complete wood floor with OSB decking
- 64-inch extra-wide doors for large equipment
- Sturdy wood framing for wind and snow loads
- Unfinished wood for personalization
Cons
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
- Paint and shingles sold separately
- Unfinished wood requires additional preparation
Good fit if
- You need wide access for large equipment
- You want a complete wood floor
- You plan to paint or stain the exterior
Skip if
- You live in Florida
- You want a pre-finished exterior
- You need roofing shingles included
Verdict: Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed suits buyers who need wide access for large equipment and a complete wood floor. It is ideal for those willing to handle painting and shingling themselves.
ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed
Best for: DIYers needing large, customizable storage space
- Material
- Treated engineered wood siding
- Footprint Size
- 24x12 ft
- Door Type
- 64-inch wide double doors
- Frame Material
- 2x4 construction
- Features
- Arched gable vents, windows, floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Large items, vertical storage
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Brookside is a 24x12 ft wooden storage shed designed for DIY assembly. It features treated engineered wood siding, 2x4 frame construction, and 7-foot sidewalls. The unit includes a floor kit, arched gable vents, and windows for airflow. You get 64-inch wide double doors for large item access. This model requires painting and shingling, which are sold separately.
Pros
- 24x12 ft footprint with 7-foot sidewalls for vertical storage
- 64-inch wide double doors for easy access
- Treated engineered wood siding resists warping and rust
- Arched gable vents and windows improve air circulation
Cons
- Assembly is estimated at 32 hours with intermediate skills
- Paint and roof shingles are not included
- Tools are not included for construction
Good fit if
- You need ample vertical space for tall items
- You want to customize the exterior appearance
- You are comfortable with a multi-day DIY project
Skip if
- You prefer a pre-assembled or snap-together structure
- You want a fully finished roof and paint included
- You lack the time for a 32-hour build
Verdict: ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wood Storage Shed suits those who prioritize customization and large capacity over quick setup. It is a solid option for DIYers who want to personalize their shed's look.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit | ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Wood | Treated engineered wood siding |
| Footprint Size | 10 x 7.5 ft | 24x12 ft |
| Door Type | 64 in extra-wide doors | 64-inch wide double doors |
| Frame Material | Wood framing | 2x4 construction |
| Features | Wood floor kit | Arched gable vents, windows, floor kit |
| Recommended Use | Large equipment | Large items, vertical storage |
| Dimensions | 64 × 90 × 90 inches | 306 × 160 × 126 inches |
| Weight | 1172 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 10x.75 | not stated |
| Color | Unfinished Wood | Unpainted |
| Model | 19641-6 | 18353-9 |
Frequently asked questions
Is a Handy Home Products shed easier to assemble than a ShedMaster model?
Both brands provide unfinished wood kits that require you to handle painting and shingling yourself. The Handy Home Olympia model weighs 1172 pounds, which suggests substantial components. You will need to manage the assembly process for either brand, as neither offers a pre-built solution.
Which shed has a larger interior floor space?
The ShedMaster Brookside offers a significantly larger footprint. It measures 160 inches wide and 306 inches long. In comparison, the Handy Home Olympia is 90 inches wide and 64 inches long. You will have much more room to store bulky items with the ShedMaster option.
Do these sheds come with a floor included?
Yes, both the Handy Home Olympia and the ShedMaster Brookside include a floor kit. The Handy Home model features an unfinished wood floor. The ShedMaster model also lists a floor in its attributes. You will have a solid base to build upon for either choice.
Can I customize the exterior appearance of these sheds?
You can customize both sheds since they arrive unfinished. The Handy Home Olympia comes in unfinished wood. The ShedMaster Brookside is listed as unpainted. You will need to apply your own paint and shingles to protect the wood and match your property's aesthetic.
Which shed is taller for vertical storage?
The ShedMaster Brookside is taller. It stands 126 inches high. The Handy Home Olympia is 90 inches high. The extra height on the ShedMaster model provides more vertical space for storing taller equipment or stacking items higher up within the structure.
Are these sheds suitable for storing large lawn equipment?
Both sheds are designed for storage, but the ShedMaster offers more capacity. Its large dimensions accommodate bulkier items better. The Handy Home Olympia is described as suitable for large equipment with wide door access. You should choose the ShedMaster if you need maximum volume for your gear.