Keter vs Rubbermaid Storage Sheds: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the keter vs rubbermaid storage shed options, you look at two distinct horizontal designs. Both are resin structures built for outdoor use and resist rust, rot, and fading. The main difference lies in their form and function. Keter offers a taller, vertical footprint with hydraulic access, while Rubbermaid provides a low-profile deck box with integrated flooring. Your choice depends on whether you need quick trash disposal or secure, seated storage for patio items.
Key differences
| Aspect | Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal Resin Shed | Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft |
|---|---|---|
| Footprint Size | 4.3 x 2.3 ft | 4.5 x 3 ft |
| Height | 45 inches | 11.8 inches |
| Door Type | Hydraulic lid | Lockable lid |
| Flooring | Not listed | Impact resistant flooring |
| Special Feature | Bin lifting system | Top doubles as seating |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal Resin Shed if
- You need to store tall items like trash cans or pool floats.
- You want hands-free lid operation for frequent access.
- You have a narrow space with limited depth.
Choose Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft if
- You prefer a low profile that blends into a deck or patio.
- You need a sturdy floor to sit on or place heavy items.
- You want to store flat items like cushions or pillows.
Verdict: Choose the Keter model if you require vertical storage and convenient hydraulic access for bulky items. Select the Rubbermaid option if you prefer a low-profile deck box with a durable floor for seating or flat storage. Both provide weather-resistant resin construction for your outdoor needs.
Keter vs Rubbermaid Shed Specs
Footprint Size
The Keter Store-It-Out Prime measures 52 inches wide by 28 inches long. This creates a narrow 4.3 by 2.3-foot footprint that fits tight patios or side yards. The Rubbermaid shed is wider at 35.8 inches but much longer at 58.5 inches. Its 4.5 by 3-foot base requires more ground space. You should measure your available area carefully. The Keter design saves width, while the Rubbermaid extends further back. Choose the Keter for narrow spots and the Rubbermaid if you have a deeper, rectangular space available for installation.
Height Profile
Height differences define the storage experience for both units. The Keter Store-It-Out Prime stands 45 inches tall. This vertical height allows for easier access without bending down too low. The Rubbermaid shed is significantly shorter at just 11.8 inches high. This low profile makes it function more like a large deck box. You will need to kneel or crouch to retrieve items from the Rubbermaid. The Keter’s taller structure offers better ergonomics for frequent access. Select the Keter if you want upright storage and easier reach.
Build Construction
Both sheds use resin to resist weather, but their internal structures differ. The Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Shed uses double-wall construction for extra strength. This dual layer provides reliable protection for tools and equipment. The Keter Store-It-Out Prime uses polypropylene resin reinforced with steel. This steel reinforcement adds rigidity to the plastic panels. The Rubbermaid also features impact-resistant flooring, which handles heavy items well. The Keter lacks a mentioned solid floor, focusing on the bin system instead. The Rubbermaid wins here for structural robustness and dedicated flooring durability.
Access Mechanism
Opening the lid is a daily task, so mechanism matters. The Keter Store-It-Out Prime includes hydraulic pistons for its lid. These pistons provide smooth operation and help lift the heavy top easily. It also features an integrated bin lifting system for trash cans. The Rubbermaid shed uses a standard lockable lid design. It does not mention hydraulic assistance or specialized lifting mechanisms. You must lift the lid manually. The Keter’s hydraulic system offers clear convenience for repeated use. The Rubbermaid relies on basic manual operation without mechanical aid.
Storage Capacity
Capacity determines what you can actually store inside. The Rubbermaid shed offers 18 cubic feet of space. This ample volume holds pillows, cushions, and pool chemicals easily. The Keter Store-It-Out Prime is described as holding up to two 32-gallon trash cans. While specific cubic footage is not listed, its compact dimensions suggest less volume than the Rubbermaid. The Rubbermaid is better for bulky items like cushions. The Keter is optimized for trash bins and smaller garden tools. If you need maximum volume, the Rubbermaid provides more interior space.
Ventilation
Airflow keeps stored items dry and prevents moisture buildup. The Keter Store-It-Out Prime includes built-in ventilation panels. These panels promote airflow to keep contents dry year-round. The Rubbermaid shed data does not mention specific ventilation features. It notes that the lid design keeps water out, but does not describe internal air circulation. Proper ventilation is important for storing sensitive materials. The Keter’s explicit ventilation panels offer a practical advantage for maintaining dry conditions inside the unit.
Which Keter or Rubbermaid Shed Fits You
You need a tall bin lift for trash cans
The Keter Store-It-Out Prime includes an integrated bin lifting system. This feature automatically raises trash can lids when you open the hydraulic lid. It offers hands-free disposal, which is convenient for daily waste management. The hydraulic pistons also ensure smooth lid operation. You get this utility without needing extra tools or modifications to your setup.
You want a sturdy floor for heavy items
The Rubbermaid shed features impact-resistant flooring built from high-quality material. This floor can handle heavy items, drops, and spills better than a flat lid. You can store patio cushions or pool chemicals safely. The double-wall construction adds extra strength. The floor provides a dedicated, durable base for your outdoor gear, protecting it from ground moisture and wear.
You need extra seating or a side table
The top of the Rubbermaid deck box doubles as extra seating or an end table. You can hold drinks or snacks on it. The clean lines and neutral tones blend into any yard. This dual function saves space on your patio. You get storage and a functional surface in one unit, making it practical for entertaining or relaxing outdoors.
The products compared
Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal Resin Shed
Best for: Small patio trash can enclosure
- Material
- Polypropylene resin
- Footprint Size
- 4.3 x 3.7 ft
- Door Type
- Double doors
- Frame Material
- Steel reinforcement
- Roof Style
- Hydraulic lid
- Features
- Hydraulic lid, vents, bin opening kit
View on Amazon: Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal Resin Shed Affiliate link
This Keter Store-It-Out Prime measures 52 by 28 by 45 inches. It features a black polypropylene resin body with steel reinforcement. The hydraulic lid opens smoothly for easy access. You get a bin lifting system for trash cans. Ventilation panels keep contents dry. This compact horizontal shed fits patios and small yards. It organizes garden tools and pool floats without taking up too much space.
Pros
- Hydraulic pistons for smooth lid operation
- Steel reinforcement resists denting and rust
- Integrated bin lifting system for trash cans
- Built-in ventilation panels for airflow
Cons
- Small 4.3 by 2.3 foot footprint
- Only one hydraulic lid door
- No mention of a floor in the specs
Good fit if
- You need to store two 32-gallon trash cans
- You have a small patio or backyard area
- You want a weather-resistant resin shed
Skip if
- You require vertical storage for tall items
- You need a large capacity for bulk supplies
- You prefer a shed with a floor
Verdict: Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal is a compact solution for small spaces. It fits you if you need to hide trash cans and keep garden tools dry.
Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft
Best for: Small patios needing seating and storage
- Material
- UV resistant resin
- Footprint Size
- 4.5 x 3 ft
- Capacity
- 18 cu ft
- Door Type
- Lockable lid
- Frame Material
- Double-wall construction
- Features
- Impact resistant flooring, lockable
View on Amazon: Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft Affiliate link
This Rubbermaid shed offers 18 cubic feet of storage in a compact 4.5 by 3 foot footprint. It features double-wall UV resistant resin construction and impact resistant flooring. The horizontal design includes a lockable lid and doubles as seating. It suits patios or decks where space is limited and you need weather protection for cushions or pool supplies.
Pros
- 18 cubic feet of storage capacity
- Double-wall UV resistant resin construction
- Impact resistant flooring
- Lockable lid for security
- Top surface doubles as seating
Cons
- Smaller 18 cu ft capacity compared to larger options
- Lock sold separately
- Limited height at 11.8 inches
Good fit if
- You need compact storage for a patio or deck
- You want a surface that doubles as seating
- You store small items like cushions or pool chemicals
Skip if
- You require vertical storage for tall tools
- You need a larger footprint for bulky equipment
- You prefer a shed with included locking mechanisms
Verdict: Rubbermaid 18 Cu Ft Horizontal Resin Shed fits small outdoor spaces where seating and storage overlap. It is ideal for protecting light gear like cushions from weather.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Keter Store-It-Out Prime Horizontal Resin Shed | Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Polypropylene resin | UV resistant resin |
| Footprint Size | 4.3 x 3.7 ft | 4.5 x 3 ft |
| Capacity | not stated | 18 cu ft |
| Door Type | Double doors | Lockable lid |
| Frame Material | Steel reinforcement | Double-wall construction |
| Roof Style | Hydraulic lid | not stated |
| Features | Hydraulic lid, vents, bin opening kit | Impact resistant flooring, lockable |
| Recommended Use | Trash cans, garden tools, pool gear | Pillows, patio cushions, pool chemicals |
| Orientation | Horizontal | Horizontal |
| Color | Black | Beige/Brown |
| Dimensions | 28 × 52 × 45 inches | 58.5 × 35.8 × 11.8 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 49.7 pounds |
| Size | Prime | 18 Ft³ Horizontal Shed |
| Model | Store-It-Out Prime 4.3 x 2.3 | FG374801OLVSS |
Frequently asked questions
Which shed is better for hiding trash cans?
The Keter Store-It-Out Prime is the better choice for trash can enclosures. Its vertical design and integrated bin lifting system allow for hands-free disposal. The black color helps it blend into outdoor spaces while keeping waste hidden and dry.
Can I sit on the Rubbermaid shed?
Yes, the Rubbermaid 18 Cu Ft Horizontal Resin Shed is designed for small patios where seating and storage overlap. Its low profile and horizontal layout allow you to use the top as a stable surface for sitting or placing cushions.
Which shed has more interior space?
The Rubbermaid shed offers 18 cubic feet of storage capacity. While the Keter model is compact, the Rubbermaid unit provides a wider base and significant length, making it ideal for storing light gear like cushions or larger garden tools.
Are these sheds made of metal?
No, both sheds are constructed from resin. This material resists rust, rot, and fading, making them suitable for outdoor use. You do not need to worry about metal corrosion or the heavy maintenance often associated with steel storage units.
Which shed is lighter to move?
The Rubbermaid shed weighs 49.7 pounds. This relatively low weight makes it easier to reposition on a patio or deck. The Keter model is also designed for compact spaces, but the specific weight data confirms the Rubbermaid unit is manageable.
Do these sheds come in different colors?
The Keter Store-It-Out Prime is available in black. The Rubbermaid 18 Cu Ft model comes in a beige and brown color combination. These neutral tones help the structures blend with various outdoor decor styles without drawing too much attention.
Which shed fits a narrow side yard?
The Keter Store-It-Out Prime fits tight spaces with its 4.3 by 2.3-foot footprint. Its horizontal orientation but vertical height allows it to utilize narrow areas effectively. The Rubbermaid shed requires more linear length, making it less suitable for very tight side yards.