ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Do-It-Yourself Wooden Storage Shed Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The shedmaster broadside 12x24 do it yourself wooden storage shed offers a massive 12x24 footprint with tall walls for vertical storage. Its wide double doors allow easy access for ATVs and large equipment. The treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed, letting you customize the exterior finish. However, the kit does not include a floor, paint, or roofing shingles. You must also plan for a significant assembly time of about 32 hours with two adults.
Some buyers may need a smaller footprint or an included floor kit to simplify construction. Others might prefer a different brand or a model with pre-installed windows. We selected 6 similar picks because their published specifications overlap with the original. These alternatives share key traits like wooden construction and DIY assembly requirements. This guide compares them based on dimensions, material quality, and included features to help you find the right fit for your property.
Our top pick: ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed.
Comparing similar wood sheds
Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop
The Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop reduces your footprint from 12x24 to 12x18, cutting interior volume significantly. At 107 inches tall, it offers less vertical clearance than the Broadside’s 121-inch height. This model includes windows, providing natural light that the original lacks. You gain a more compact structure suitable for focused DIY projects rather than storing large machinery. The 1971-pound weight suggests a robust build, but you sacrifice the wide garage-style door access needed for ATVs. If your equipment fits within a 12x18 space and you prioritize a lit workspace over maximum capacity, this is a strong alternative.
ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed
The ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed shrinks the footprint dramatically to 12x10, making it unsuitable for large equipment like ATVs. At 120 inches square, it matches the Broadside’s height but offers far less floor space. This model includes a floor kit, saving you the effort of sourcing materials separately, which the original does not. The 1600-pound weight indicates a sturdy frame, but the 120-inch width limits door access for wide items. You should pick this if you need a smaller, wind-resistant storage solution for tools and garden supplies rather than vehicle storage. The included floor is a practical advantage for smaller yards.
ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed
The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed offers a 12x16 footprint, reducing length by eight feet compared to the Broadside. At 137 inches tall, it provides greater vertical clearance, enhancing shelving options. This model includes both a floor and a loft, adding storage versatility that the original lacks. The 146-inch width is narrower, which may restrict access for very wide equipment. You gain a loft for overhead storage but lose the extensive linear space needed for long items. This is a better choice if you need vertical organization and loft space within a smaller footprint, rather than the maximum ground area of the 12x24 model.
Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed
The Handy Home Products Astoria 12x20 Wooden Shed reduces the footprint from 12x24 to 12x20, cutting four feet of length. At 119 inches tall, it is slightly shorter than the Broadside’s 121-inch height. This model includes a floor kit, simplifying installation compared to the original which requires you to source one separately. The 157-inch width matches the Broadside, preserving wide door access for large equipment. You gain a pre-built floor but sacrifice four feet of interior length. This is a practical option if you need tall vertical storage and wide access but require a smaller overall footprint that still accommodates substantial machinery.
ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed
The ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed narrows the width from 12 feet to 10 feet, which may restrict access for wide ATVs or large equipment. At 120 inches tall, it matches the Broadside’s height but offers less floor space. This model includes a floor kit and dual entryways, providing convenient pedestrian access that the original lacks. The 136-inch width is significantly narrower, impacting maneuverability for large items. You gain dual doors and a floor but lose the wide garage-style opening and maximum footprint. Pick this if you need separate pedestrian and equipment access within a narrower space, rather than the broad access of the 12x24 model.
Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed
The Handy Home Products Cedarhill 12x20 Wooden Shed reduces the footprint from 12x24 to 12x20, cutting four feet of length. At 126 inches tall, it offers greater vertical clearance than the Broadside’s 121-inch height. This model includes a floor kit, saving you from sourcing materials separately. The 160-inch width is slightly wider, potentially aiding access for very large items. You gain extra height and a floor but lose linear storage space. This is a suitable alternative if you prioritize vertical storage capacity and a wider frame for large equipment, while accepting a shorter overall length than the 12x24 Broadside.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed
Best for: storing ATVs and tall equipment
- Material
- Treated engineered wood siding
- Footprint Size
- 12 x 24 ft
- Frame Material
- 16 in. on-center wall studs
- Assembly
- Pre-cut wood kit, 2 adults, 32 hours
- Roof Style
- 10 ft. overall height
- Recommended Use
- ATV units and large equipment
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Broadside is a 12x24 foot DIY wooden storage shed designed for large equipment. It features 7-foot side walls and a 10-foot overall height for vertical storage. The structure includes 8-foot double garage-style doors and a 32-inch side entry door. Built with treated engineered wood and 16-inch on-center studs, it offers a durable frame. You get a large footprint for ATV units, though assembly takes about 32 hours.
Pros
- 12x24 foot footprint provides large storage capacity
- 7-foot side walls allow for vertical shelving
- 8-foot double doors accommodate ATVs and large gear
- Treated engineered wood resists warping and rust
Cons
- Assembly requires 32 hours and two adults
- Floor kit is not included in the package
- Paint and roofing shingles are sold separately
Good fit if
- You need space for ATV units or large equipment
- You want to customize the exterior finish yourself
- You have time for a multi-day DIY project
Skip if
- You need a pre-assembled structure for immediate use
- You want a complete kit with floor and roof
- You prefer a smaller footprint for tight spaces
Verdict: ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wooden Shed is the best choice for users needing maximum interior volume for large equipment. Its tall design and wide doors make it ideal for storing ATVs and tall tools, provided you are ready for a significant assembly commitment.
Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop
Best for: DIY workshop projects in a 12x18 space
- Material
- LP SmartSide siding, 2x4 wood framing
- Footprint Size
- 12x18 ft
- Capacity
- 216 sq. ft. interior
- Door Type
- Double doors, 60 in. W x 72 in. H
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing
- Interior Dimensions
- 144 in. W x 216 in. L x 107 in. H
View on Amazon: Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop Affiliate link
This 12x18 wooden shed offers 216 square feet of interior space for tools and lawn equipment. It features 6-foot sidewalls, 2x4 wood framing, and LP SmartSide siding. The unit includes a pre-assembled floor and operable windows for natural light. Double doors provide wide access. It is designed for DIY assembly with pre-cut, labeled lumber.
Pros
- 216 sq. ft. interior capacity
- 60-inch wide double doors
- LP SmartSide siding with 50-year warranty
- Includes treated wood floor
- Operable windows for ventilation
Cons
- Smaller footprint than 12x24 alternatives
- Requires painting and shingling separately
- Heavy at 1971 pounds
Good fit if
- You need a dedicated workshop space
- You want natural light for tasks
- You prefer a smaller footprint than 12x24
Skip if
- You require a 12x24 footprint
- You want a fully pre-finished structure
- You need a floor included in the base price without extra options
Verdict: Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Value Workshop Shed fits those who need a sturdy, well-lit workspace in a compact 12x18 footprint. It suits buyers who do not need the full 12x24 size and are willing to add their own paint and shingles.
ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed
Best for: smaller storage needs with a floor kit
- Material
- Treated engineered wood siding
- Footprint Size
- 12x10 ft
- Frame Material
- 2 x 4 framing, 24 in. on-center studs
- Assembly
- Pre-cut wood kit; 2+ adults; 8 hours
- Recommended Use
- Customizable wooden shed
- Features
- Floor
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Meadowview is a 12x10 foot DIY wooden storage shed with a complete floor kit. It features 2x4 framing rated for 115 mph winds and 23 psf snow loads. You get two door options and three operational windows with screens. The treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed for painting. This kit requires eight hours of assembly by two adults.
Pros
- Complete floor system included in the kit
- 2x4 framing supports 115 mph winds
- Three operational windows with screens
- Two door locations for flexible access
- Factory-primed treated engineered wood siding
Cons
- Smaller 12x10 footprint compared to 12x16 or 12x20 alternatives
- Paint and roof shingles are not included
- Assembly requires eight hours and power tools
Good fit if
- You need a complete floor system without buying extras
- You want customizable door and window placement
- You have space for a 12x10 foot structure
Skip if
- You require a larger 12x18 or 12x24 footprint
- You want a pre-painted finished product
- You prefer a metal or plastic material
Verdict: ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed offers a sturdy, floor-inclusive option for those needing a smaller footprint. It suits buyers who prioritize wind resistance and customization over maximum storage volume. The included floor saves you from sourcing materials separately.
ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed
Best for: DIYers wanting a floor and loft
- Material
- Treated engineered wood
- Footprint Size
- 12x16 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in pre-hung double doors
- Frame Material
- Heavy-duty wood structure
- Assembly
- 2 adults, 24 hours, intermediate skill
- Features
- Storage loft, window, wood floor kit
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 is a DIY wooden storage shed with a floor kit. It measures 12 by 16 feet with a height of 137 inches. The unit features treated engineered wood siding that is factory-primed. You get a storage loft and a window for natural light. The 64-inch pre-hung double doors allow easy access for lawn equipment. This model is designed for homeowners who want to customize the exterior finish themselves.
Pros
- Includes a complete wood floor system
- 64-inch pre-hung double doors for wide access
- Factory-primed siding ready for your paint choice
- Built-in storage loft for extra space
- Window provides natural interior light
Cons
- Assembly requires at least two adults
- Paint and roof shingles are sold separately
- Expected assembly time is 24 hours
Good fit if
- You want a floor included in the kit
- You plan to paint the siding yourself
- You need wide door access for equipment
Skip if
- You want a fully assembled unit delivered
- You prefer metal or plastic construction
- You need a smaller footprint under 12 feet
Verdict: The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wood Shed offers a solid DIY option with a floor and loft. It suits buyers who want to customize the exterior and need wide access for large items.
Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed
Best for: DIYers needing tall vertical storage
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12x20 ft
- Roof Style
- 9 ft 11 in peak height
- Features
- 7 ft tall side walls
- Recommended Use
- Ladders, rakes, shovels
- Color
- Brown
View on Amazon: Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Astoria is a 12x20 foot wooden storage shed with 7-foot side walls and a 9-foot 11-inch peak height. You get extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors with continuous galvanized steel hinges. The floor is not included, allowing you to build a custom foundation like a cement pad. It is designed for vertical storage of long items like ladders and rakes.
Pros
- 7-foot tall side walls for vertical storage
- 9-foot 11-inch peak height
- Extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors
- Continuous galvanized steel hinges
- Custom foundation compatibility
Cons
- Floor kit is not included
- Paint and shingles are sold separately
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
Good fit if
- You need to store tall items like ladders
- You want to build a custom foundation
- You prefer to paint and finish the wood yourself
Skip if
- You live in Florida
- You want a pre-built floor included
- You need a smaller footprint than 12x20 feet
Verdict: The Handy Home Products Astoria 12x20 Wooden Shed offers tall vertical storage and wide doors for easy access. It is a practical option for DIYers who want to customize their foundation and finish.
ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed
Best for: dual-entry storage with tall wall clearance
- Footprint Size
- 10x20 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing
- Features
- 7 ft. side wall height, floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Long-handled tools, bulky items
- Dimensions
- 258 × 136 × 120 inches
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed Affiliate link
This ShedMaster wooden shed provides a 10x20-foot footprint built with 2x4 framing and pre-primed LP SmartSide siding. You get 7-foot side walls for tall equipment and two distinct access points, including 64-inch double doors and a 32-inch side door. A wood floor kit is included in the package. It suits buyers needing drive-in clearance alongside separate pedestrian access.
Pros
- Includes a factory wood floor kit
- Two entry points with 64-inch double doors and a 32-inch side door
- Tall 7-foot side walls accommodate vertical tool storage
- Built with sturdy 2x4 framing and LP SmartSide siding
Cons
- Narrower 10-foot footprint compared to 12-foot alternative widths
- No windows included in the design specifications
Good fit if
- You need dual entry points for separate equipment and pedestrian access.
- You want 7-foot interior side walls for storing tall tools.
- You prefer a building package that includes a matching floor kit.
Skip if
- You require a wider 12-foot building width.
- You want an outbuilding design that incorporates windows.
Verdict: ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed with Floor Kit provides dual entryways and tall 7-foot walls for organized property storage. It fits owners who need separate pedestrian and equipment access within a 10-foot-wide footprint.
Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed
Best for: Storing large lawn tractors and ATVs
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12 x 20 ft
- Door Type
- 8 ft. wide double doors
- Assembly
- Pre-cut components, DIY assembly
- Features
- Two windows, 7 ft. high side walls
- Recommended Use
- Large lawn tractors, ATVs
View on Amazon: Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed Affiliate link
The Handy Home Products Cedarhill is a 12x20 foot wooden storage shed designed for large equipment. It features 7-foot high side walls and 8-foot wide double doors, making it suitable for lawn tractors and ATVs. The kit includes two windows for natural light and ventilation. You get pre-cut components for DIY assembly. Note that the floor kit, paint, and roofing shingles are not included in the package.
Pros
- 12x20 foot footprint provides ample space
- 8-foot wide double doors allow easy access
- 7-foot high side walls accommodate tall items
- Two windows provide natural light and ventilation
- Pre-cut components simplify DIY assembly
Cons
- Floor kit is not included
- Paint and roofing shingles are not included
- Requires custom foundation installation
Good fit if
- You need space for large lawn tractors or ATVs
- You want natural light and ventilation in your shed
- You prefer to install your own custom foundation
Skip if
- You want a complete kit with floor and roof
- You prefer a pre-painted structure
- You need a smaller footprint than 12x20 feet
Verdict: The Handy Home Products Cedarhill 12x20 Wooden Shed fits buyers who need a spacious, customizable wooden structure for large equipment. It is ideal if you plan to install your own foundation and add your own roof and paint.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed | Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop | ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed | ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed | Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed | ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed | Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Treated engineered wood siding | LP SmartSide siding, 2x4 wood framing | Treated engineered wood siding | Treated engineered wood | Wood | not stated | Wood |
| Footprint Size | 12 x 24 ft | 12x18 ft | 12x10 ft | 12x16 ft | 12x20 ft | 10x20 ft | 12 x 20 ft |
| Capacity | not stated | 216 sq. ft. interior | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Door Type | not stated | Double doors, 60 in. W x 72 in. H | not stated | 64 in pre-hung double doors | not stated | not stated | 8 ft. wide double doors |
| Frame Material | 16 in. on-center wall studs | 2x4 wood framing | 2 x 4 framing, 24 in. on-center studs | Heavy-duty wood structure | not stated | 2x4 wood framing | not stated |
| Assembly | Pre-cut wood kit, 2 adults, 32 hours | not stated | Pre-cut wood kit; 2+ adults; 8 hours | 2 adults, 24 hours, intermediate skill | not stated | not stated | Pre-cut components, DIY assembly |
| Roof Style | 10 ft. overall height | not stated | not stated | not stated | 9 ft 11 in peak height | not stated | not stated |
| Features | not stated | not stated | not stated | Storage loft, window, wood floor kit | 7 ft tall side walls | 7 ft. side wall height, floor kit | Two windows, 7 ft. high side walls |
| Interior Dimensions | not stated | 144 in. W x 216 in. L x 107 in. H | not stated | 146 in W x 195 in L x 137 in H | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Recommended Use | ATV units and large equipment | Tools, lawn equipment, large items | Customizable wooden shed | Lawn tractors, mowers, bicycles | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Long-handled tools, bulky items | Large lawn tractors, ATVs |
| Color | Unpainted | Brown | Unpainted | Unpainted | Brown | Unpainted | Unpainted |
| Dimensions | 295 × 157 × 121 inches | 216 × 144 × 107 inches | 146 × 120 × 120 inches | 195 × 146 × 137 inches | 243 × 157 × 119 inches | 258 × 136 × 120 inches | 257 × 160 × 126 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 1971 pounds | 1600 pounds | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Model | 18521-2 | 12x18 VWS-PC-FK | 18454-3 | 18272-3 | 19419-1 | 18496-3 | 18029-3 |
| Size | not stated | 12x18 | not stated | 12x16 | 12x20 | not stated | not stated |
If you need indoor organization, specs for the best bookcases with storage detail interior dimensions and shelf weight capacities.
Frequently asked questions
How much interior space does the ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 provide?
The ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 offers a substantial footprint measuring 157 inches wide by 295 inches long. With a height of 121 inches, it provides ample vertical clearance for tall equipment. This volume makes it suitable for storing large items like ATVs, though assembly is required.
Does the ShedMaster Broadside include a floor kit?
Yes, the ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed includes a floor. This feature saves you from sourcing separate materials for a base. It provides a sturdy foundation for your storage needs, allowing you to focus on assembling the walls and roof.
What is the height of the Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Workshop?
The Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop stands 107 inches tall. This is shorter than the Broadside’s 121-inch height. It offers a compact 12x18 footprint with a weight of 1971 pounds, making it a sturdy option for DIY workshops in smaller spaces.
Are windows included with the Little Cottage Co. 12x18?
Yes, the Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop includes windows. This feature provides natural light for your workspace. It is a practical addition for DIY projects, distinguishing it from models that rely solely on artificial lighting or door openings for visibility.
What are the dimensions of the ShedMaster Westfield 12x16?
The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed measures 146 inches wide, 195 inches long, and 137 inches high. It includes a floor and loft for extra storage. This model is designed for DIYers who want to customize the exterior finish while having a solid base.
How wide is the Handy Home Astoria 12x20 shed?
The Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed is 157 inches wide. It stands 119 inches tall and spans 243 inches in length. This model offers tall vertical storage and wide doors for easy access, making it a practical choice for DIYers needing to customize their foundation.
Does the ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 have dual entryways?
Yes, the ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed provides dual entryways. It features tall 7-foot walls for organized property storage. This design fits owners who need separate pedestrian and equipment access within a 10-foot-wide footprint, offering flexibility for different types of stored items.
What is the weight of the ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10?
The ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed weighs 1600 pounds. It measures 120 inches wide, 146 inches long, and 120 inches high. This model includes a floor kit, saving you from sourcing materials separately, and is ideal for buyers prioritizing wind resistance and customization.