6 Best Alternatives to the ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Do-It-Yourself Wooden Storage Shed (2026)
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The shedmaster brookside 24x12 do it yourself wooden storage shed offers a massive 24x12 footprint for large DIY projects. It features treated engineered wood siding, 2x4 construction, and 64-inch double doors. You get ample vertical space with 7-foot sidewalls and natural light from arched gable vents and windows. The unit includes a floor kit and requires assembly with power tools.
You might look for alternatives if you need a smaller footprint, a different material, or a pre-assembled unit. This list covers 6 options chosen because their specs overlap with the original. Some picks offer metal construction for rust resistance. Others provide narrower profiles for tight patios. Several include operable windows or specific shelving configurations. Each alternative matches specific needs that the Brookside model may not address, such as compact garden storage or dedicated workshop lighting.
Our top pick: ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed.
How these alternatives compare
Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed
The Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed is much smaller than the ShedMaster Brookside. It measures 72.5 inches wide and 52.2 inches long, compared to the Brookside’s 160 by 306 inches. You sacrifice significant interior volume for a compact footprint that fits small yards. This unit weighs 108 pounds, making it lighter than the heavy wooden structures. It offers standing height at 78.1 inches. You get a rust-resistant metal build instead of wood. This option suits buyers who need a standalone unit without the massive space requirements of the Brookside.
GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet focuses on vertical organization rather than floor space. It measures only 36.8 inches wide and 16.5 inches long. This is far narrower than the ShedMaster Brookside’s 160-inch width. You give up the large double-door access and vast interior volume. Instead, you get a metal-reinforced front and adjustable shelving for tools. The cabinet stands 67.1 inches tall. It weighs 77 pounds, which is significantly less than the Brookside. This choice fits tight spaces where vertical access matters more than storing large lawn equipment or bulky items.
HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed
The HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed is designed for narrow patios. It is much slimmer than the ShedMaster Brookside, which spans 160 inches in width. You trade the large 24x12 footprint for a narrow profile that fits in constrained outdoor areas. This unit emphasizes vertical storage for gardening tools. It features a solid wood build and an elevated floor for moisture protection. The Anthracite Grey finish differs from the Brookside’s unpainted wood. You do not get the wide 64-inch double doors or the extensive sidewall height of the Brookside. It is best for organized tool storage in limited spaces.
Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop
The Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop is smaller than the ShedMaster Brookside. It measures 120 inches wide and 144 inches long, compared to the Brookside’s 160 by 306 inches. You lose the massive interior volume and the 7-foot sidewalls. However, this shed offers operable windows for better ventilation and natural light. It includes pre-assembled doors for easier installation. The brown finish is ready for use, unlike the unpainted Brookside siding. It weighs 1178 pounds. This option suits users who prioritize workshop functionality and door access over the sheer size and DIY customization potential of the Brookside.
Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
The Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed is significantly smaller than the ShedMaster Brookside. It measures 90 inches wide and 64 inches long, versus the Brookside’s 160 by 306 inches. You sacrifice a large portion of the floor area and interior height. This shed offers a robust foundation with a complete floor kit. It includes wide doors for access, similar to the Brookside. The unfinished wood requires you to apply paint and shingles yourself, just like the Brookside. It weighs 1172 pounds. This choice fits DIYers who want a smaller structure with a wood floor and do not need the expansive storage of the 24x12 model.
Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
The Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed is closer in size to the ShedMaster Brookside but still smaller. It measures 160 inches wide, matching the Brookside’s width, but is only 209 inches long compared to 306 inches. You lose the full 24x12 footprint and the associated interior volume. This shed provides ample room for large items and tools. It features unfinished wood siding that requires customization. The structure weighs 1929 pounds, indicating a sturdy build. It includes a floor kit. You get similar durability and DIY requirements but in a more compact footprint that may fit tighter spaces than the Brookside.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed
Best for: large DIY storage projects with customization needs
- Material
- Treated engineered wood siding
- Footprint Size
- 24x12 ft
- Door Type
- 64-inch wide double doors
- Frame Material
- 2x4 construction
- Features
- Arched gable vents, windows, floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Large items, vertical storage
View on Amazon: ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed Affiliate link
The ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 is a large DIY wooden storage shed designed for substantial outdoor storage. It features a 24x12 foot footprint with 2x4 frame construction and treated engineered wood siding. The unit includes a floor kit, arched gable vents, and windows for airflow. You get 64-inch wide double doors and 7-foot sidewalls for easy access and vertical space. Assembly is required and takes approximately 32 hours.
Pros
- 24x12 foot footprint provides ample storage volume
- 64-inch wide double doors allow large item access
- 7-foot sidewalls offer significant vertical storage height
- Includes floor kit and arched gable vents
Cons
- Requires 32 hours of DIY assembly time
- Paint and shingles are not included
- Tools are not included for construction
Good fit if
- You need a large footprint for bulky equipment
- You want to customize the exterior finish
- You have the time for a multi-day build
Skip if
- You want a pre-assembled unit
- You need a smaller 6x4 or 10x7.5 footprint
- You prefer metal or plastic materials
Verdict: ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Storage Shed fits users who prioritize maximum interior volume and customization over quick installation. It is ideal for those with space for a 24x12 structure who are willing to invest the time in assembly.
Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed
Best for: compact metal storage with standing height
- Material
- Electro-galvanized steel
- Footprint Size
- 6 x 4 ft
- Capacity
- 130 cu ft
- Door Type
- Lockable door
- Frame Material
- Steel frame
- Assembly
- 2 to 3 people, 4 to 5 hours
View on Amazon: Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed Affiliate link
This Panovue unit is a 6 by 4 foot steel storage shed with a light wood grain finish. It offers 130 cubic feet of interior space and reaches a max height of 78.1 inches. The electro-galvanized steel frame resists rust and UV damage. You get a lockable door with a broad entrance for easy access. Assembly takes 4 to 5 hours with two to three people.
Pros
- Electro-galvanized steel frame resists rust and deformation
- 130 cubic feet of interior storage capacity
- Lockable door with broad entrance for easy access
- Max height of 78.1 inches allows standing inside
Cons
- Smaller 6 by 4 foot footprint than the 24 by 12 foot Brookside
- Requires 4 to 5 hours to assemble with two to three people
- Sold without a base or floor kit
Good fit if
- You need a compact, rust-resistant unit for small yards
- You want a structure that allows you to stand inside
- You prefer metal durability over wooden construction
Skip if
- You require a large 24 by 12 foot storage area
- You want a pre-assembled floor included in the box
- You need a structure taller than 78.1 inches
Verdict: Panovue 6x4ft Metal Garden Shed is a compact, rust-resistant option for small yards. It suits buyers who need a standalone metal unit with standing height but do not require the massive footprint of the Brookside 24x12.
GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame
Best for: compact vertical tool organization
- Material
- Metal frame, wooden structure
- Footprint Size
- 2.5 x 1.4 ft
- Door Type
- Lockable door
- Frame Material
- Metal frame
- Roof Style
- Sloped roof
- Features
- Three adjustable shelves, wooden floor
View on Amazon: GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame Affiliate link
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet combines a wooden structure with a reinforced metal front frame for added stability. Its footprint measures 2.5 by 1.4 feet, making it a compact option for patios or decks. You get three adjustable shelves and a raised wooden floor to keep gear dry. The sloped roof sheds water effectively. This unit stands 67.1 inches tall and weighs 77 pounds.
Pros
- Reinforced metal front frame for stability
- Three adjustable interior shelves
- Raised wooden floor prevents water ingress
- Sloped roof design sheds water
Cons
- Small footprint limits bulk storage
- No mention of ventilation features
- Weight may require careful placement
Good fit if
- You need vertical storage for hand tools
- You have limited patio space
- You want a sturdy frame for wind resistance
Skip if
- You need to store large lawn mowers
- You require extensive horizontal shelving
- You want a wide base for stability
Verdict: The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet fits tight spaces where vertical access matters more than floor area. It suits users prioritizing a metal-reinforced front and adjustable shelving for organized tool storage.
HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed
Best for: narrow patios and vertical tool storage
- Material
- Solid wood
- Assembly
- Clear part numbers, complete hardware
- Features
- Elevated floor, 2 adjustable shelves
- Recommended Use
- Tools, pool supplies, lawn equipment
- Orientation
- Vertical
- Dimensions
- 17.7 × 17.7 × 71 inches
View on Amazon: HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed Affiliate link
The HABAU 71" vertical shed offers tall, narrow storage for gardens or patios. Its solid wood construction includes an elevated floor to prevent water seepage and a weather-resistant gray finish. Inside, two adjustable shelves allow you to organize tools and supplies, while removable shelves accommodate taller items like mops. This unit is ideal for small outdoor spaces where footprint matters more than width.
Pros
- Solid wood construction for durability
- Elevated floor prevents water seepage
- Two adjustable interior shelves
- Weather-resistant anthracite grey finish
Cons
- Narrow 17.71-inch footprint limits wide item storage
- 71-inch height may not fit under low eaves
- No mention of locking mechanism in specs
Good fit if
- You have limited horizontal space on a patio
- You need vertical storage for tall garden tools
- You prefer solid wood over plastic or metal
Skip if
- You require a large footprint for bulk equipment
- You need a wide opening for lawnmowers
- You want a pre-assembled unit without installation
Verdict: HABAU 71" Vertical Wooden Storage Shed fits users with narrow outdoor spaces who need tall, organized storage for gardening tools. Its solid wood build and elevated floor provide practical protection against moisture.
Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop
Best for: workshops needing operable windows and large doors
- Material
- LP SmartSide siding, primed
- Footprint Size
- 10 x 12 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls
- Assembly
- Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware
- Recommended Use
- Tools, lawn equipment, large items
- Features
- Floor, Windows
View on Amazon: Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop Affiliate link
This 10x12 wooden shed offers 120 square feet of interior space with 6-foot sidewalls and 2x4 framing. It includes a treated wood floor and operable windows for natural light. The LP SmartSide siding is primed and ready for paint. It features large 60x72 inch pre-assembled double doors for easy access to tools and lawn equipment. This kit is designed for DIY assembly with pre-cut, labeled wood.
Pros
- Operable windows provide natural interior lighting
- Spacious 120 sq. ft. interior with 6 ft. sidewalls
- Large 60 in. W x 72 in. H pre-assembled double doors
- Includes complete wood floor with treated 2x4 framing
Cons
- Smaller 10x12 footprint compared to other options
- Siding is primed and requires custom painting
- Heavy 1178-pound weight requires liftgate delivery
Good fit if
- You need operable windows for ventilation and light
- You want a pre-assembled double door for large items
- You plan to paint the LP SmartSide siding yourself
Skip if
- You require a larger 24x12 footprint
- You prefer a shed that arrives fully painted
- You cannot accommodate a 10x12 footprint
Verdict: Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Workshop Shed fits buyers who prioritize natural light and large door access for workshop use. Its operable windows and pre-assembled doors make it a practical choice for storing lawn equipment and tools in a dedicated outdoor space.
Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: DIYers needing wide doors and a wood floor
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10 x 7.5 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in extra-wide doors
- Frame Material
- Wood framing
- Features
- Wood floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Large equipment
View on Amazon: Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
This unfinished wood storage shed measures 10 by 7.5 feet with a 90-inch height. It includes a sturdy wood floor kit with OSB decking and framing. The 64-inch extra-wide doors allow easy access for large equipment. You get a durable structure built to handle wind and snow loads. This model is a practical option for DIYers who want to customize the finish with their own paint and shingles.
Pros
- Includes complete wood floor kit with OSB decking
- 64-inch extra-wide doors for large equipment access
- Sturdy wood framing designed for wind and snow loads
- Unfinished wood allows for custom paint and shingle choices
Cons
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
- Requires separate purchase of paint and roofing shingles
- Heavy weight of 1172 pounds requires careful handling
Good fit if
- You need wide doors for large equipment storage
- You want to customize the exterior finish yourself
- You prefer a complete wood floor kit included
Skip if
- You live in Florida due to regional restrictions
- You need a pre-finished structure without extra purchases
- You require a smaller footprint than 10 by 7.5 feet
Verdict: Handy Home Products Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed offers a robust foundation for DIY enthusiasts who value wide access and a complete floor. It suits those ready to invest time in finishing the wood and shingles themselves.
Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: large tool and equipment storage
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12 x 16 ft
- Assembly
- Do-it-yourself kit
- Features
- Floor kit included
- Dimensions
- 209 × 160 × 126 inches
- Weight
- 1929 pounds
View on Amazon: Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit Affiliate link
This Handy Home Products Scarsdale shed offers a 12 by 16 foot footprint for substantial storage. It is a do-it-yourself wooden kit that includes a floor kit. The structure measures 209 inches in length and 160 inches in width. You get 126 inches of height. The unfinished wood requires your own paint. It suits those needing a large, permanent outdoor storage solution.
Pros
- Generous 12x16 foot footprint
- Includes floor kit
- 126 inches of interior height
- Durable wooden construction
Cons
- Heavy 1929 pound weight
- Requires DIY assembly
- Unfinished wood needs painting
Good fit if
- You need maximum storage space
- You want a sturdy wooden structure
- You have time for assembly
Skip if
- You want a pre-finished building
- You need a small footprint
- You prefer professional installation
Verdict: Handy Home Products Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed provides ample room for large items. It fits buyers who prioritize size and durability over convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | ShedMaster Brookside 24x12 Wooden Shed | Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed | GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame | HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed | Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop | Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit | Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Treated engineered wood siding | Electro-galvanized steel | Metal frame, wooden structure | Solid wood | LP SmartSide siding, primed | Wood | Wood |
| Footprint Size | 24x12 ft | 6 x 4 ft | 2.5 x 1.4 ft | not stated | 10 x 12 ft | 10 x 7.5 ft | 12 x 16 ft |
| Capacity | not stated | 130 cu ft | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Door Type | 64-inch wide double doors | Lockable door | Lockable door | not stated | not stated | 64 in extra-wide doors | not stated |
| Frame Material | 2x4 construction | Steel frame | Metal frame | not stated | 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls | Wood framing | not stated |
| Assembly | not stated | 2 to 3 people, 4 to 5 hours | not stated | Clear part numbers, complete hardware | Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware | not stated | Do-it-yourself kit |
| Roof Style | not stated | Sloping roof | Sloped roof | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Features | Arched gable vents, windows, floor kit | 1 clear window, lockable door | Three adjustable shelves, wooden floor | Elevated floor, 2 adjustable shelves | not stated | Wood floor kit | Floor kit included |
| Interior Dimensions | not stated | not stated | 16.5 x 36.8 x 67.1 in | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Recommended Use | Large items, vertical storage | Mowers, shovels, ladders, bikes | Garden tools, outdoor equipment | Tools, pool supplies, lawn equipment | Tools, lawn equipment, large items | Large equipment | not stated |
| Orientation | not stated | not stated | not stated | Vertical | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Color | Unpainted | Light Wood Grain | Brown | Anthracite Grey | Brown | Unfinished Wood | Unfinished Wood |
| Dimensions | 306 × 160 × 126 inches | 52.2 × 72.5 × 78.1 inches | 16.5 × 36.8 × 67.1 inches | 17.7 × 17.7 × 71 inches | 144 × 120 × 102 inches | 64 × 90 × 90 inches | 209 × 160 × 126 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 108 pounds | 77 pounds | not stated | 1178 pounds | 1172 pounds | 1929 pounds |
| Model | 18353-9 | metal shed | AIR7004-N | not stated | 10x12 VWS-PC-FK | 19641-6 | 19527-3 |
| Size | not stated | 6X4FT [Without Base] | not stated | 71" | 10x12 | 10x.75 | 12x16 |
If you need interior shelving instead of outdoor space, you can evaluate dimensions for the best bookcases with storage.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a metal alternative to the ShedMaster Brookside for small yards?
Yes, the Panovue 6x4 ft Metal Garden Shed offers a rust-resistant option for compact spaces. It measures 72.5 inches wide and 52.2 inches long, providing standing height without the massive footprint of the Brookside. It is ideal for buyers who need a standalone unit with a light wood grain finish.
What is the best vertical storage shed for narrow patios?
The HABAU 71" Vertical Wood Storage Shed is designed for narrow outdoor areas. It features a solid wood build and an elevated floor to protect against moisture. This unit is best for users who need tall, organized storage for gardening tools in limited spaces, with an anthracite grey color option.
Which shed includes operable windows for a workshop?
The Little Cottage Co. 10x12 Wood Workshop includes operable windows to provide natural light. It also features large doors for easy access to lawn equipment and tools. This model measures 120 inches wide and 144 inches long, making it a practical choice for dedicated outdoor workspace needs.
Is there a DIY shed with a wide door and floor kit?
The Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit is built for DIY enthusiasts. It offers wide access and a complete wood floor foundation. The unit measures 90 inches wide and 64 inches long, requiring you to finish the wood and shingles yourself for a customized look.
What is the largest wood shed listed for tool storage?
The Handy Home Scarsdale 12x16 Wood Shed with Floor Kit provides ample room for large items. It measures 160 inches wide and 209 inches long, offering significant storage capacity. This model is best for buyers who prioritize size and durability over quick installation convenience.
Is there a compact cabinet for vertical tool organization?
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame fits tight spaces where vertical access matters. It measures 36.8 inches wide and 67.1 inches high, featuring a metal-reinforced front and adjustable shelving. This brown unit is ideal for organized tool storage in gardens or outdoors.