Suncast Outdoor Storage Shed vs Suncast 5.9' x 3.7' Horizontal Stow-Away Storage Shed (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you research suncast outdoor storage shed vs 5 9 x 3 7 horizontal stow away storage, you see two distinct designs from the same brand. Both units use durable multi-wall resin panels for all-weather protection. The main difference lies in their orientation and capacity. One is a tall vertical cabinet, while the other is a wide horizontal shed with a hinged lid. You need to decide which footprint and access style fit your yard and storage needs.
Key differences
| Aspect | Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed | Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Orientation | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Capacity | 54 cu. ft. | not listed |
| Footprint Size | 34.6 x 71.5 inches | 5.9 x 3.7 ft |
| Height | 11.5 inches | 52 inches |
| Door Type | Lockable handles | Hinged lid |
| Weight | 102 pounds | not listed |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed if
- You need to store long-handled tools like rakes or shovels upright
- You have limited ground space but ample vertical clearance
- You prefer a padlock-ready design for secure item storage
Choose Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed if
- You want to store bulky items like bicycles or firewood
- You prefer a soft-close hinged lid with gas shocks for easy access
- You need a wider footprint to fit two large waste containers
Verdict: The vertical shed suits those with narrow spaces who need to store tall gardening tools. The horizontal shed is better for users who prioritize wide access and want to store larger, bulkier items. Choose the model that matches your available floor space and the shape of your gear.
Size, Shape, and Storage Style
Orientation
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed stands tall, designed to accommodate long-handled tools like rakes and shovels without bending them. Its vertical profile maximizes floor space efficiency, making it ideal for tight patios or narrow garden corners. In contrast, the Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed lies low to the ground. This horizontal orientation suits items that do not require vertical clearance, such as bulkier gardening supplies or wide containers. You should choose the vertical model for height-constrained areas needing tall storage, while the horizontal unit fits better where ceiling height is not an issue but ground space is available.
Capacity
Capacity defines how much you can store inside each unit. The vertical shed offers 54 cubic feet of space, a substantial volume for organizing seasonal decorations, cushions, or extensive tool collections. This large interior volume allows you to stack items efficiently from bottom to top. The horizontal shed does not list a specific cubic footage in its published specifications, but its footprint of 5.9 by 3.7 feet provides a wide, shallow storage area. This layout is excellent for items like two 96-gallon waste containers or firewood that need width rather than height. If total volume is your priority, the vertical option provides a clear numerical advantage.
Dimensions
Physical dimensions determine where each shed can fit in your outdoor space. The vertical unit measures 34.6 inches in width, 71.5 inches in length, and 11.5 inches in height, presenting a narrow but deep footprint that extends significantly upward. The horizontal shed is wider at 70.5 inches, deeper at 43.8 inches, but much shorter at 52 inches. This makes the horizontal model better for covering larger ground areas, such as sitting over trash bins, while the vertical model requires less ground square footage. You need to measure your patio or garden area carefully, as the vertical shed’s height is a major factor in placement stability and wind exposure.
Access Mechanism
How you access your stored items affects daily convenience. The vertical shed features lockable handles that are padlock-ready, allowing you to secure the doors with your own lock. The resin lower latch keeps the doors closed securely against wind. The horizontal shed uses a hinged lid that opens upward. It includes gas shocks to keep the lid open hands-free, which is helpful when you are holding items. A soft-close hinge prevents the lid from slamming shut, protecting your fingers and the unit’s structure. If you prefer side access with traditional door locking, the vertical shed is better. If you want easy overhead access with assisted opening, the horizontal model wins.
Recommended Use
Each shed is engineered for specific types of storage. The vertical shed is recommended for garden tools, patio cushions, and general outdoor items. Its reinforced floor supports heavy items, making it suitable for storing power tools or heavy planters. The horizontal shed is specifically noted as perfect for storing up to two 96-gallon waste containers, bicycles, or firewood. This makes it an ideal solution for hiding trash bins from street view or storing bulky, irregularly shaped items that do not fit well in a tall, narrow cabinet. Your choice depends on whether you need to organize vertical tools or hide large, wide objects.
Which suncast shed fits your needs
Gardeners with long-handled tools
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed features a tall profile that accommodates rakes and shovels without bending. Its vertical orientation maximizes floor space efficiency, making it ideal for narrow patios. The reinforced floor supports heavy items, while the multi-wall resin panels provide durable, all-weather protection for your gardening supplies.
Users storing large bulky items
This horizontal unit offers a wide footprint of 5.9 by 3.7 feet, perfect for storing two 96-gallon waste containers, bicycles, or firewood. The hinged lid opens fully, and gas shocks keep it open for easy access. The soft-close hinge prevents slamming, ensuring safe and convenient storage for larger, bulkier outdoor equipment.
People seeking easy lid operation
The Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed includes gas shocks that make lifting the lid effortless. It stays open securely while you work. The soft-close hinge prevents the lid from slamming shut, protecting your fingers and the unit. This design simplifies daily access to stored items without requiring extra effort.
The products compared
Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed
Best for: storing tall garden tools in narrow spaces
- Material
- Multi-wall resin
- Capacity
- 54 cu. ft.
- Door Type
- Padlock-ready lockable handles
- Recommended Use
- Long-handled tools, patio umbrellas
- Orientation
- Vertical
- Dimensions
- 71.5 × 34.6 × 11.5 inches
View on Amazon: Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed Affiliate link
This Suncast vertical storage shed offers 54 cubic feet of space in a tall, narrow footprint. Measuring 71.5 inches long, 34.6 inches wide, and 11.5 inches high, it fits well against walls or in tight corners. The multi-wall resin panels provide water resistance and UV protection. It includes a reinforced floor for heavy items and padlock-ready handles for security. Assembly requires minimal tools.
Pros
- 54 cubic feet of vertical storage capacity
- Multi-wall resin panels for durability and weather resistance
- Reinforced floor supports heavy garden tools
- Padlock-ready handles for added security
Cons
- Vertical orientation limits width for bulky items
- Padlock not included with the unit
- No mention of a base or floor anchor system
Good fit if
- You need to store long-handled tools like rakes or shovels
- You have limited floor space but available height
- You want a low-maintenance outdoor cabinet for patio cushions
Skip if
- You require a horizontal layout for wider equipment
- You prefer a shed with a built-in floor base
- You need immediate lock security without buying a padlock
Verdict: Suncast 54 cu ft Vertical Resin Shed is a practical option for storing tall garden tools in tight spaces. It suits buyers who prioritize vertical height over wide floor area and want a durable, weather-resistant cabinet for their patio or garden.
Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed
Best for: Small patios storing two 96-gallon waste containers
- Material
- Resin
- Capacity
- 70 cu ft
- Door Type
- Front doors, top-loading lid
- Frame Material
- Steel-reinforced multi-wall panels
- Features
- Floor, gas shocks, soft-close hinge
- Recommended Use
- Two 96-gallon trash cans, bikes
View on Amazon: Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed Affiliate link
This Suncast horizontal storage shed offers a 5.9 by 3.7 foot footprint for compact outdoor organization. Its all-weather resin construction provides water resistance and UV protection. The hinged lid features gas shocks for easy lifting and a soft-close hinge to prevent slamming. You can store two 96-gallon waste containers, bicycles, or firewood inside. It is ideal for small patios or tight spaces where vertical height is limited.
Pros
- Gas shocks keep the lid open while in use
- Soft-close hinge prevents lid from slamming shut
- Multi-wall resin panels offer strength and durability
- Water-resistant and UV-protected all-weather construction
Cons
- Horizontal layout limits vertical storage height
- Single hinged lid restricts wide item access
- No ventilation features mentioned in specifications
Good fit if
- You need to store two 96-gallon waste containers
- You have limited vertical clearance on your patio
- You want a compact footprint for bicycles or firewood
Skip if
- You require easy access to wide items like lawnmowers
- You need significant vertical storage space for tall gear
- You prefer a large footprint for bulkier equipment
Verdict: Suncast 5.9' x 3.7' Horizontal Resin Shed fits users with tight spaces who need to store two 96-gallon waste containers or bicycles without taking up much ground area.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed | Suncast 5.9 x 3.7 ft Horizontal Stow-Away Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Multi-wall resin | Resin |
| Capacity | 54 cu. ft. | 70 cu ft |
| Door Type | Padlock-ready lockable handles | Front doors, top-loading lid |
| Frame Material | not stated | Steel-reinforced multi-wall panels |
| Features | not stated | Floor, gas shocks, soft-close hinge |
| Recommended Use | Long-handled tools, patio umbrellas | Two 96-gallon trash cans, bikes |
| Orientation | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Dimensions | 71.5 × 34.6 × 11.5 inches | 43.8 × 70.5 × 52 inches |
| Weight | 102 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 54 CU FT. | not stated |
| Color | Taupe | Vanilla, Stoney, and Black |
| Model | BMS5700D | BMS4720 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Suncast shed is better for storing two trash cans?
The Suncast 5.9' x 3.7' Horizontal Stow-Away Shed is the better choice for this task. Its horizontal layout and specific dimensions are designed to fit two 96-gallon waste containers efficiently. The vertical model is too narrow for this purpose, making the horizontal unit the practical option for waste management storage.
What are the exact dimensions of the horizontal stow-away model?
The Suncast 5.9' x 3.7' Horizontal Stow-Away Shed measures 70.5 inches in width, 43.8 inches in length, and 52 inches in height. These specifications provide a wide footprint that maximizes ground-level storage. You can use these numbers to ensure the unit fits your available patio or deck space.
How much total storage volume does the vertical shed offer?
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed provides 54 cubic feet of storage space. This capacity is achieved through its tall design, which measures 71.5 inches in height. This volume is ideal for bulky items or tall garden tools that require significant vertical clearance.
Is the vertical shed suitable for narrow garden corners?
Yes, the Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed is well-suited for narrow spaces. It has a width of only 34.6 inches, allowing it to fit into tight gaps. Its vertical orientation maximizes storage without requiring a large floor area, making it a space-efficient solution for small gardens.
What color options are available for the horizontal shed?
The Suncast 5.9' x 3.7' Horizontal Stow-Away Shed comes in Vanilla, Stoney, and Black. These color choices allow you to match the shed to your existing outdoor decor. The vertical model is listed in Taupe, offering a different aesthetic option depending on your preference.
Can the vertical shed store cushions comfortably?
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed is recommended for storing cushions. Its vertical design keeps items upright and organized. While it excels with tall tools, the ample height allows for stacking or storing bulky soft items like patio cushions without them taking up excessive floor space.
Which model is lighter to move if needed?
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed weighs 102 pounds. This weight makes it manageable for relocation compared to larger, heavier structures. While the horizontal model's weight is not specified, the vertical unit’s specific mass helps you plan for moving it during cleaning or reorganization.