Suncast vs Rubbermaid: Storage Sheds Compared by Specs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing suncast vs rubbermaid storage shed options, you are choosing between two resin brands that prioritize weather resistance. Both units use durable resin materials to resist rust, rot, and fading in outdoor environments. The main difference lies in their orientation and capacity. Suncast offers a tall vertical design for long tools, while Rubbermaid provides a low horizontal profile for broader items. Your choice depends on whether you need height or floor space.
Key differences
| Aspect | Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed | Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 54 cu. ft. | 18 cu. ft. |
| Orientation | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Footprint Size | 34.6 inches wide, 71.5 inches long | 35.8 inches wide, 58.5 inches long |
| Construction | Multi-wall panels | Double-wall construction |
| Flooring | Reinforced floor | Impact resistant flooring |
| Weight | 102 pounds | 49.7 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed if
- You need to store long-handled garden tools or patio umbrellas that require vertical height.
- You want a larger storage volume of 54 cubic feet for bulky items.
- You prefer a unit that doubles as a stable base for heavy items due to its reinforced floor.
Choose Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft if
- You have limited floor space but need a wider storage area for cushions or pillows.
- You want a lighter unit that is easier to move or reposition around your patio.
- You prefer a low-profile design that can also serve as extra seating or a side table.
Verdict: Choose the Suncast if your primary need is storing tall, long-handled tools in a compact footprint. Choose the Rubbermaid if you need a versatile, low-profile box for cushions and pool supplies that can also double as seating. Both offer weather-resistant resin construction for long-term outdoor use.
Suncast and Rubbermaid Shed Specs
Capacity and Size
The Suncast model offers 54 cubic feet of storage space, making it significantly larger than the Rubbermaid option at 18 cubic feet. This difference in volume affects how you organize your items. The Suncast unit stands vertically, allowing you to store tall, long-handled garden tools, patio umbrellas, and other vertical equipment without bending. The Rubbermaid unit lies horizontally, providing a lower profile that fits well under decks or on patios. While the Suncast has a wider footprint, the Rubbermaid’s compact 4.5 by 3 feet base saves ground space. You should choose the Suncast if you need to store bulky or tall items, and the Rubbermaid if you only need to keep small cushions or pool supplies accessible.
Material and Build
Both sheds utilize resin construction to resist weather elements, but the specific engineering differs. The Suncast shed uses multi-wall panels to ensure strength and longevity, providing water resistance and UV protection. This design helps the structure maintain its integrity against outdoor conditions. The Rubbermaid shed features double-wall construction, which provides extra strength and durability for protecting valuable tools and landscaping materials. Both materials are impact resistant and will not rust or rot. The Suncast panels are designed for an all-weather design, while the Rubbermaid lid has an innovative design to keep water out. You get reliable protection from either brand, though the multi-wall and double-wall approaches offer different structural benefits.
Orientation and Profile
The orientation of these sheds dictates how they fit into your outdoor layout. The Suncast is a vertical storage cabinet, which maximizes height rather than width. This tall profile is ideal for keeping the floor area clear while storing items that need to stand upright. The Rubbermaid is a horizontal shed with a floor, which keeps the center of gravity lower. This horizontal design allows the top of the unit to double as extra seating or an end table for holding drinks. The Suncast requires more vertical clearance, while the Rubbermaid blends into yard spaces with clean lines and a neutral tone. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize vertical storage capacity or a multi-purpose low profile.
Security Features
Both units include lockable mechanisms to secure your stored items, though neither includes the lock itself. The Suncast shed comes with padlock-ready lockable handles and a resin lower latch that keeps the doors securely closed. This setup allows you to attach your own padlock through the handles for added security. The Rubbermaid shed features a lockable lid design, also requiring a separate lock purchase. Both systems provide a basic level of deterrence against casual theft. You will need to buy a padlock separately for either unit. The Suncast offers a latch system in addition to the handle locks, while the Rubbermaid relies on the lid closure mechanism. Both are sufficient for keeping contents safe from unauthorized access.
Weight and Portability
The weight of each shed impacts how difficult it is to move or assemble. The Suncast unit weighs 102 pounds, reflecting its larger 54 cubic feet capacity and multi-wall construction. This weight provides stability but makes it harder to relocate once set up. The Rubbermaid unit is much lighter at 49.7 pounds, due to its smaller 18 cubic feet size and horizontal design. This lower weight makes the Rubbermaid easier to move if you need to reconfigure your patio or yard layout. The Suncast is designed for a permanent or semi-permanent location, while the Rubbermaid’s lighter build offers more flexibility. You should consider how often you might need to shift these units when deciding between the two.
Which Storage Shed Suits Your Needs
You need tall storage for long tools
The Suncast model stands vertically with a height of 71.5 inches. This tall profile accommodates long-handled garden tools and patio umbrellas easily. Its 54 cubic feet of capacity provides ample room for bulky items. The reinforced floor supports heavy equipment without bending. You get a dedicated vertical space that keeps tall items upright and organized.
You want extra seating on your deck
The Rubbermaid unit features a horizontal design with a flat top. This surface doubles as extra seating or a small end table. Its compact 18 cubic feet footprint fits neatly on patios or decks. The 4.5 by 3 feet size saves space while storing cushions or pillows. You gain functional furniture that also protects your outdoor gear from weather.
You prefer a lightweight, portable unit
The Rubbermaid shed weighs only 49.7 pounds, making it much lighter than the Suncast option. Its double-wall construction offers durability without adding excessive mass. The horizontal layout keeps the center of gravity low for stability. You can move it easily if needed. The impact-resistant floor handles spills and drops, ensuring long-term use in high-traffic areas.
The products compared
Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed
Best for: Tall tools and narrow outdoor spaces
- Material
- Multi-wall resin
- Capacity
- 54 cu. ft.
- Door Type
- Padlock-ready lockable handles
- Recommended Use
- Long-handled tools, patio umbrellas
- Orientation
- Vertical
- Dimensions
- 71.5 × 34.6 × 11.5 inches
View on Amazon: Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed Affiliate link
This Suncast vertical shed offers 54 cubic feet of storage in a tall, narrow footprint. Measuring 71.5 inches long and 34.6 inches wide, it fits well in tight outdoor spaces. The multi-wall resin panels provide water resistance and UV protection. A reinforced floor supports heavy garden items. You get padlock-ready handles for security, though the padlock itself is not included. It is a low-maintenance option for patio or garden use.
Pros
- 54 cubic feet of vertical storage capacity
- Multi-wall resin panels for durability and UV protection
- Reinforced floor designed to hold heavy items
- Padlock-ready handles for added security
- Minimal tools required for assembly
Cons
- Padlock is not included with the unit
- Narrow width limits side-by-side storage
- No mention of a built-in floor or shelving system
Good fit if
- You have limited width but plenty of vertical space
- You need to store long-handled tools or umbrellas
- You want a water-resistant outdoor cabinet for patio items
Skip if
- You need a wide base for bulky equipment
- You prefer a shed with a built-in floor
- You want a padlock included in the box
Verdict: Suncast 54 Cu Ft Vertical Resin Shed is a space-saving solution for storing tall garden tools and patio cushions. It suits buyers who prioritize vertical height over floor width and need a durable, weather-resistant cabinet for their outdoor area.
Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft
Best for: small patio spaces and cushion storage
- Material
- UV resistant resin
- Footprint Size
- 4.5 x 3 ft
- Capacity
- 18 cu ft
- Door Type
- Lockable lid
- Frame Material
- Double-wall construction
- Features
- Impact resistant flooring, lockable
View on Amazon: Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft Affiliate link
This Rubbermaid horizontal shed offers 18 cubic feet of storage in a compact 4.5 by 3 foot footprint. It features double-wall UV resistant resin construction and impact-resistant flooring. The beige and brown design blends into patios or yards. You can use the top as extra seating. It is lockable for security, though you must supply your own lock. This unit suits small outdoor spaces.
Pros
- Double-wall resin construction for strength
- Impact-resistant flooring handles heavy items
- UV resistant material prevents fading
- Top doubles as seating or table
Cons
- Small 18 cubic foot capacity
- Lock sold separately
- Horizontal orientation limits vertical storage
Good fit if
- You have limited deck or patio space
- You need to store patio cushions or pillows
- You want a low-profile storage solution
Skip if
- You require large volume for garden tools
- You need vertical storage for tall items
- You want a lock included in the box
Verdict: Rubbermaid 4.5 x 3 Ft Horizontal Resin Shed fits buyers with tight patio spaces who need to store cushions or small items. It offers durable double-wall construction but lacks included locking hardware.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed | Rubbermaid Small Horizontal Resin Shed 18 cu ft |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Multi-wall resin | UV resistant resin |
| Footprint Size | not stated | 4.5 x 3 ft |
| Capacity | 54 cu. ft. | 18 cu ft |
| Door Type | Padlock-ready lockable handles | Lockable lid |
| Frame Material | not stated | Double-wall construction |
| Features | not stated | Impact resistant flooring, lockable |
| Recommended Use | Long-handled tools, patio umbrellas | Pillows, patio cushions, pool chemicals |
| Orientation | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Dimensions | 71.5 × 34.6 × 11.5 inches | 58.5 × 35.8 × 11.8 inches |
| Weight | 102 pounds | 49.7 pounds |
| Size | 54 CU FT. | 18 Ft³ Horizontal Shed |
| Color | Taupe | Beige/Brown |
| Model | BMS5700D | FG374801OLVSS |
Frequently asked questions
Which shed is better for storing long garden tools?
The Suncast 54 cu. ft. Vertical Resin Shed is the better choice for long tools. Its vertical orientation and 71.5-inch height accommodate tall items like shovels and rakes easily. The Rubbermaid model is horizontal and only 11.8 inches high, making it unsuitable for long-handled equipment.
Do these sheds require assembly?
The provided specifications do not mention assembly requirements for either unit. You should check the manufacturer instructions for setup details. Both sheds are constructed from resin, which typically involves snapping panels together, but specific assembly steps are not listed in the current data.
How heavy are these storage sheds?
The Suncast shed weighs 102 pounds, while the Rubbermaid shed weighs 49.7 pounds. The Suncast unit is more than twice as heavy due to its larger 54 cubic feet capacity. The Rubbermaid model is lighter, which may make it easier to move if needed.
What colors are available for these resin sheds?
The Suncast vertical shed is available in Taupe. The Rubbermaid horizontal shed comes in a Beige/Brown color combination. These neutral tones help the sheds blend into outdoor patio or garden environments. Specific color options for other models are not provided in the current data.
Are these sheds suitable for pool cushions?
Yes, both sheds are recommended for storing pool cushions. The Rubbermaid model explicitly lists cushion storage as a recommended use. The Suncast shed also mentions patio cushions in its recommended uses. Their resin construction helps protect cushions from weather elements.
Which shed has a larger footprint?
The Suncast shed has a larger footprint in terms of length, measuring 71.5 inches long. The Rubbermaid shed is 58.5 inches long. However, the Suncast is narrower at 34.6 inches wide compared to the Rubbermaid's 35.8 inches. The Suncast utilizes vertical space, while the Rubbermaid spreads out more horizontally.
Is locking hardware included with these sheds?
The provided data does not specify if locking hardware is included with either the Suncast or Rubbermaid sheds. You may need to purchase a padlock separately. Always verify the package contents with the manufacturer before relying on built-in security features for your stored items.