6 Best Alternatives to the Handy Home Products Astoria 12x12 Do-It-Yourself Wooden (2026)
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be looking for handy home products astoria 12x12 do it yourself wooden alternatives because this shed has specific traits that do not fit every yard. The original model offers a 12x12 footprint with 7-foot side walls and a 9-foot-11-inch peak height. Its 2x4 wood framing provides strong vertical storage for ladders and long tools. However, it does not include a floor kit, requiring you to build a custom foundation. It also lacks pre-finished siding, meaning you must buy and apply your own paint and shingles.
These alternatives were chosen because their specifications overlap with the original in key areas like material and frame strength. Some options provide included floors, saving you construction time. Others offer different footprints, such as 8x10 or 10x14, which may better suit your available space. Some models include windows for natural light, while others focus on compact organization for smaller gardens. You can select a version that matches your preferred size, height, or feature set without starting from scratch.
Our top pick: Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed.
How these sheds differ from the Astoria
Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop Shed
The Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop is smaller than the Astoria, with a footprint of 8x10 feet versus 12x12 feet. It weighs 946 pounds, significantly less than the Astoria’s 1500 pounds. This model includes windows for natural light, which the Astoria lacks. It also features a floor kit, saving you the step of building a custom base. The peak height is 96.5 inches, lower than the Astoria’s 119 inches. You should choose this if you need a workshop with ventilation and a ready-to-use floor, and if your yard space is tighter than the Astoria requires. It is a budget-friendly option for smaller storage needs.
Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 Wood Shed
The Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 offers a different shape than the Astoria. It is wider at 169 inches long but narrower at 134 inches wide, compared to the Astoria’s 147x157 inches. It weighs 1070 pounds, lighter than the Astoria’s 1500 pounds. The height is 114 inches, slightly lower than the Astoria’s 119 inches. Like the Astoria, it is an unfinished wood shed that requires you to build your own foundation and apply your own finish. This model is better if you prefer a rectangular footprint that is longer than it is wide. It provides substantial vertical storage for tall items, similar to the Astoria, but with a different ground coverage layout.
Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed
The Handy Home Braymore 10x14 is taller than the Astoria, with a peak height of 134 inches versus 119 inches. It weighs 1700 pounds, making it the heaviest option here. The footprint is 122 inches wide and 171 inches long, offering more length than the Astoria. It is also an unfinished wood structure requiring a custom foundation and exterior finish. You should pick this if you need extra vertical clearance for very tall equipment or ladders. The Braymore provides a robust frame for heavy-duty storage. It is ideal for DIYers who want the most height available in a wooden shed kit and do not mind the additional weight and larger length.
GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet is a compact alternative, measuring 36.8 inches wide and 16.5 inches long. It is much smaller than the Astoria’s 12x12 footprint. Weighing only 77 pounds, it is extremely lightweight compared to the Astoria’s 1500 pounds. It includes a floor and is designed for garden tool organization. This unit is not a full shed but a cabinet with a metal frame. You should choose this if you have limited space and only need to store hand tools or small items. It is suitable for users who want a finished, ready-to-use unit without the complexity of building a large wooden structure or foundation.
Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
The Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 is smaller than the Astoria, with a footprint of 10x7.5 feet. It weighs 1172 pounds, lighter than the Astoria. The height is 90 inches, significantly lower than the Astoria’s 119 inches. It includes a floor kit, which the Astoria does not. This model is designed for wide access to bulky gear. You should pick this if you need a smaller shed with a built-in floor and do not require the tall vertical storage of the Astoria. It is a good choice for smaller yards where the Astoria’s 12x12 footprint would be too large. The Olympia offers a sturdy frame for DIY assembly with less height constraint.
Handy Home Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed with Floor
The Handy Home Charleston 10x10 has a smaller footprint than the Astoria, measuring 10x10 feet. It weighs 907 pounds, much lighter than the Astoria’s 1500 pounds. The height is 120 inches, slightly taller than the Astoria’s 119 inches. It includes a floor kit, unlike the Astoria. The Charleston is beige, while the Astoria is brown. You should choose this if you want a square footprint with a built-in floor and slightly more height. It is suitable for storing long-handled tools in a space that is smaller than the Astoria’s 12x12 area. This model offers a solid DIY option with an included floor and tall walls for vertical storage.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed
Best for: storing tall ladders and bulky equipment
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 12x12 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing
- Roof Style
- 9 ft 11 in peak height
- Features
- 7 ft tall side walls
- Recommended Use
- Ladders, rakes, shovels
The Handy Home Products Astoria 12x12 is a large wooden storage shed with a 12x12 foot footprint. It features 7-foot tall side walls and a 9-foot 11-inch peak height, allowing you to store tall items like ladders and rakes. The structure uses 2x4 wood framing for strength. It comes without a floor, letting you build a custom foundation. This shed is designed for DIY assembly and personalization with paint and shingles.
Pros
- 12x12 foot footprint offers ample storage space
- 7-foot side walls and nearly 10-foot peak height accommodate tall equipment
- 2x4 wood framing provides structural strength from ground to peak
- Extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors allow easy access
Cons
- Floor is not included, requiring you to build or buy a separate foundation
- Paint and shingles are sold separately, adding to the final setup
- Heavy weight of 1500 pounds makes it difficult to move once assembled
Good fit if
- You need a large footprint for bulky yard tools and ladders
- You want to build a custom foundation like a concrete pad
- You plan to paint and shingle the shed yourself
Skip if
- You want a shed that includes a pre-built floor
- You prefer a ready-to-use structure without buying separate paint and shingles
- You have limited space smaller than 12x12 feet
Verdict: Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wooden Shed is a sturdy, high-ceiling option for those who need maximum vertical storage and are willing to build a custom base. It fits users who want to customize the exterior finish themselves.
Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop Shed
Best for: customizable workshops with natural light
- Material
- LP SmartSide siding, primed
- Footprint Size
- 8 x 10 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls
- Assembly
- Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware
- Features
- Operable window, no floor included
- Recommended Use
- Tools, lawn equipment, large items
This 8x10 wooden shed offers 80 square feet of interior space for tools and lawn equipment. It features 6-foot sidewalls and 2x4 framing designed to withstand heavy snow and wind. The LP SmartSide siding is primed for painting, and the kit includes an operable window for natural light. You get pre-cut wood and hardware for assembly, though the floor is not included in this specific configuration.
Pros
- 80 square feet of interior storage space
- LP SmartSide siding primed and ready to paint
- Operable window for ventilation and light
- 48-inch by 72-inch pre-assembled double doors
Cons
- Floor is not included in this kit
- Requires custom foundation installation
- Paint and shingles must be purchased separately
Good fit if
- You need a workshop with natural light
- You want to customize the exterior finish
- You prefer a smaller 8x10 footprint
Skip if
- You need a shed with a built-in floor
- You want a larger 10x14 or 12x12 space
- You prefer a pre-finished exterior
Verdict: Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop fits buyers who want a customizable workshop with good ventilation and sturdy framing. It is ideal for those willing to add a floor and finish the siding themselves.
Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 Wood Shed
Best for: DIYers needing tall vertical storage space
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10x14 ft
- Frame Material
- 2x4 wood framing
- Assembly
- Do-It-Yourself, floor not included
- Roof Style
- 9'-6" peak height
- Features
- 7' tall side walls, floor not included
The Handy Home Products Rookwood 10x14 is a do-it-yourself wooden storage shed with a 10x14 foot footprint. It features 2x4 wood framing and 7-foot tall side walls for vertical storage. The interior measures 134 by 169 inches. You must provide your own floor and finish materials. This structure suits those needing extra height for tall equipment.
Pros
- 7-foot tall side walls
- 2x4 wood framing
- 134 by 169 inch interior
- 9.5-foot peak height
Cons
- Floor kit not included
- Paint and shingles sold separately
- Not available in Florida
Good fit if
- You need tall vertical storage
- You want to build a custom foundation
- You prefer to finish the exterior yourself
Skip if
- You want a complete kit with floor
- You live in Florida
- You need a pre-finished structure
Verdict: The Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 Wooden Shed offers substantial height and a large footprint for DIY builders who want to customize their foundation and exterior finish.
Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed
Best for: tall tool storage and custom foundations
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10x14 ft
- Roof Style
- Gambrel roof, 11 ft 5 in peak height
- Features
- 7 ft tall side walls
- Recommended Use
- Ladders, rakes, shovels
- Color
- Brown
The Handy Home Products Braymore is a 10x14 ft wooden storage shed with a traditional gambrel roof. It features 7 ft tall side walls and an 11 ft 5 in peak height, offering ample vertical space for long items like ladders and rakes. The unit includes extra-large 5 ft 4 in wide doors with continuous galvanized steel hinges. It is sold without a floor kit or paint, allowing for custom foundation choices.
Pros
- 10x14 ft footprint provides substantial storage volume
- 11 ft 5 in peak height accommodates tall equipment
- 5 ft 4 in wide doors allow easy access
- Gambrel roof design maximizes interior headroom
Cons
- Floor kit is not included in the package
- Requires separate purchase of paint and shingles
- Not available for sale in Florida due to weather restrictions
Good fit if
- You need vertical clearance for ladders or rakes
- You prefer a traditional barn-style aesthetic
- You want to install a custom foundation like concrete
Skip if
- You live in Florida due to shipping restrictions
- You want a ready-to-use floor included
- You prefer a smaller 8x10 or 10x10 footprint
Verdict: The Handy Home Products Braymore 10x14 Wooden Shed is ideal for those needing tall storage for long tools and who want to customize their foundation and finish.
GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame
Best for: compact garden tool organization
- Material
- Metal frame, wooden structure
- Footprint Size
- 2.5 x 1.4 ft
- Door Type
- Lockable door
- Frame Material
- Metal frame
- Roof Style
- Sloped roof
- Features
- Three adjustable shelves, wooden floor
View on Amazon: GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame
This GUTINNEEN outdoor cabinet measures 36.8 inches wide and 67.1 inches high. It features a reinforced metal front frame and a wooden structure. The interior includes three adjustable shelves and a raised wooden floor. The sloped roof sheds water effectively. With a footprint of 2.5 by 1.4 feet, it fits tight spaces. You can use it for garden tools or outdoor equipment on patios or decks.
Pros
- Reinforced metal front frame for stability
- Three adjustable interior shelves
- Raised wooden floor prevents water ingress
- Sloped roof design sheds water
Cons
- Small 2.5 by 1.4 foot footprint
- No ventilation mentioned for interior air flow
- Lockable door lacks specific lock type details
Good fit if
- You need a narrow cabinet for tight corners
- You want adjustable shelving for varied tool sizes
- You prefer a metal-reinforced front for durability
Skip if
- You require a full-size shed for large equipment
- You need a wide base for stability on uneven ground
- You want a completely wooden structure without metal
Verdict: GUTINNEEN Metal-Frame Wooden Garden Shed offers a compact, reinforced option for small gardens. It suits users with limited space who need organized, dry storage for hand tools and small equipment.
Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
Best for: Storing large equipment with wide access
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10 x 7.5 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in extra-wide doors
- Frame Material
- Wood framing
- Features
- Wood floor kit
- Recommended Use
- Large equipment
View on Amazon: Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit
The Handy Home Olympia is a 10x7.5 ft unfinished wooden storage shed designed for large equipment. It features a complete wood floor with framing and OSB decking. The 64-inch extra-wide doors simplify access to bulky items. The sturdy wood construction handles wind and snow loads. You need to buy paint and shingles separately to finish the build.
Pros
- Complete wood floor kit with framing
- 64-inch extra-wide doors
- Sturdy wood construction for snow loads
- 10x7.5 ft footprint
Cons
- Smaller 10x7.5 ft footprint than most alternatives
- Unfinished wood requires separate paint and shingles
- Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions
Good fit if
- You need wide doors for large equipment
- You want a complete wood floor included
- You are okay with finishing the exterior yourself
Skip if
- You live in Florida
- You need a larger footprint
- You want a pre-finished structure
Verdict: The Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed suits those needing wide access for bulky gear. Its included wood floor and sturdy frame make it a solid DIY project for smaller yards.
Handy Home Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed with Floor
Best for: storing long-handled tools in a beige wooden shed
- Material
- Wood
- Footprint Size
- 10 x 10 ft
- Door Type
- 64 in double doors
- Frame Material
- 2x3 framing
- Assembly
- Pre-cut wood kit, common household tools
- Roof Style
- Gable, 8 ft peak, 6 ft sidewalls
View on Amazon: Handy Home Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed with Floor
This 10x10 ft wooden shed features a beige finish and a gable roof with an 8 ft peak. It includes a complete wood floor with OSB decking and 2x3 framing. The 64-inch double doors provide wide access, while full-length galvanized steel hinges ensure durability. It is designed for DIY assembly using common tools and suits users needing space for long-handled tools.
Pros
- Includes complete wood floor with framing and OSB decking
- Extra-wide 64-inch double doors for easy entry
- Tall 8 ft peak with 6 ft sidewalls for tall items
- Full-length galvanized steel hinges for strength
Cons
- Requires purchasing paint and shingles separately
- Pre-cut kit requires assembly with common household tools
- 907-pound weight makes it bulky to move
Good fit if
- You need a beige wooden shed with a floor included
- You want to store long-handled tools requiring vertical height
- You prefer wide double doors for easy access
Skip if
- You need a pre-assembled unit without DIY work
- You want a shed that includes paint and shingles
- You require a smaller footprint than 10x10 ft
Verdict: Handy Home Products Charleston Value 10x10 Beige offers a spacious 10x10 ft footprint with an included floor and tall walls, making it a solid choice for users who need vertical storage for long-handled tools and do not mind DIY assembly.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed | Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop Shed | Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 Wood Shed | Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed | GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet with Metal Frame | Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed with Floor Kit | Handy Home Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed with Floor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Wood | LP SmartSide siding, primed | Wood | Wood | Metal frame, wooden structure | Wood | Wood |
| Footprint Size | 12x12 ft | 8 x 10 ft | 10x14 ft | 10x14 ft | 2.5 x 1.4 ft | 10 x 7.5 ft | 10 x 10 ft |
| Door Type | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified | Lockable door | 64 in extra-wide doors | 64 in double doors |
| Frame Material | 2x4 wood framing | 2x4 wood framing, 6 ft. sidewalls | 2x4 wood framing | not specified | Metal frame | Wood framing | 2x3 framing |
| Assembly | not specified | Pre-cut, labeled wood kit with hardware | Do-It-Yourself, floor not included | not specified | not specified | not specified | Pre-cut wood kit, common household tools |
| Roof Style | 9 ft 11 in peak height | not specified | 9'-6" peak height | Gambrel roof, 11 ft 5 in peak height | Sloped roof | not specified | Gable, 8 ft peak, 6 ft sidewalls |
| Features | 7 ft tall side walls | Operable window, no floor included | 7' tall side walls, floor not included | 7 ft tall side walls | Three adjustable shelves, wooden floor | Wood floor kit | not specified |
| Interior Dimensions | not specified | not specified | 134 in W x 169 in L x 114 in H | not specified | 16.5 x 36.8 x 67.1 in | not specified | not specified |
| Recommended Use | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Tools, lawn equipment, large items | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Ladders, rakes, shovels | Garden tools, outdoor equipment | Large equipment | Long-handled tools |
| Color | Brown | Brown | Brown | Brown | Brown | Unfinished Wood | Beige |
| Dimensions | 147 × 157 × 119 inches | 120 × 96 × 96.5 inches | 169 × 134 × 114 inches | 171 × 122 × 134 inches | 16.5 × 36.8 × 67.1 inches | 64 × 90 × 90 inches | 120 × 96 × 120 inches |
| Weight | 1500 pounds | 946 pounds | 1070 pounds | 1700 pounds | 77 pounds | 1172 pounds | 907 pounds |
| Size | 12x12 | 8x10 | 10x14 | 10x14 | not specified | 10x.75 | 10x10 |
| Model | 19413-9 | 8x10 VWS-PC | 19432-0 | 19454-2 | AIR7004-N | 19641-6 | 19272-2 |
If you want different dimensions, you can compare office star products osp home furnishings sierra alternatives for your space.
Frequently asked questions
What is the largest footprint available in this list?
The Handy Home Astoria 12x12 Wood Shed offers the largest footprint at 12 by 12 feet. Its width measures 157 inches and its length is 147 inches. This substantial size provides maximum vertical storage for tall ladders and bulky equipment. It weighs 1500 pounds, making it the heaviest option on the list.
Which shed is best for small gardens with limited space?
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet is the most compact choice. It measures 36.8 inches wide and 16.5 inches long. Weighing only 77 pounds, it fits easily into tight corners. This metal-frame wooden unit is designed for organizing hand tools and small garden equipment in areas where a full-sized shed would not fit.
How tall is the tallest shed in the group?
The Handy Home Braymore 10x14 Wood Shed is the tallest at 134 inches. Its peak height allows for storing long-handled tools and tall ladders. The shed weighs 1700 pounds and features a 10 by 14 foot footprint. This height makes it ideal for DIYers needing maximum vertical clearance for bulky gear.
Do any of these sheds come with a floor included?
Several models include a floor. The Handy Home Olympia 10x7.5 Wood Shed and the Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed both come with an included wood floor kit. The Astoria and Rookwood models list a floor as a feature but do not specify inclusion in the same way. The GUTINNEEN cabinet also lists a floor feature.
Which option provides natural light for a workshop?
The Little Cottage Co. 8x10 Value Workshop Shed is the only model listed with windows. These windows provide natural light, making it suitable for use as a customizable workshop. It measures 96 inches wide and 120 inches long. The inclusion of windows sets it apart from the other all-wood options in this guide.
What is the lightest shed on this list?
The GUTINNEEN Outdoor Storage Cabinet is the lightest at 77 pounds. Its compact dimensions of 36.8 inches wide and 67.1 inches high make it easy to move. In contrast, the Handy Home Astoria weighs 1500 pounds. The GUTINNEEN unit is designed for users who need dry storage without the weight of a large structure.
Is there a beige option available in this selection?
Yes, the Handy Home Charleston 10x10 Wood Shed with Floor is available in beige. It measures 96 inches wide and 120 inches long. This model offers a spacious 10 by 10 foot footprint with tall walls for vertical storage. It is one of the few options that provides a specific beige color finish.
Which shed has the longest length dimension?
The Handy Home Rookwood 10x14 Wood Shed has the longest length at 169 inches. It also measures 134 inches wide and 114 inches high. Weighing 1070 pounds, it offers a large footprint for DIY builders. This length provides ample space for storing long items and bulky equipment compared to the smaller 8x10 models.