Handy Home Products Cedarhill 12x20 Wooden Storage Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

How These Sheds Differ From The Original

Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop

The Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop is slightly smaller than the original, measuring 144 by 216 inches. It includes a floor and windows, which the original requires you to supply separately. At 1971 pounds, it is a heavy structure. The brown finish is included, saving you painting time. You get less interior length but gain a complete, ready-to-use base. This model suits those who want a finished look without extra construction steps. The 107-inch height is lower than the original's 126 inches, which may limit clearance for very tall equipment. It is a solid choice for tool storage where maximum vertical space is not critical.

ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed

The ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed is significantly smaller, with a footprint of 120 by 146 inches. It includes a floor, unlike the original kit. The height matches the original at 120 inches, offering similar vertical clearance. Weighing 1600 pounds, it is lighter and easier to handle during assembly. This unit is designed for smaller yards where space is limited. You sacrifice over 100 square feet of floor area for a more compact structure. The unpainted wood requires the same finishing work as the original. It is best for buyers who need a sturdy, complete floor but do not require drive-in storage for large vehicles. It fits tight spaces where the 12x20 size would be overwhelming.

ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed

The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Storage Shed is smaller in length, measuring 146 by 195 inches. It includes a floor and a loft, features the original lacks. The height is 137 inches, providing more vertical space than the original's 126 inches. This extra height allows for better overhead storage organization. The unpainted wood requires the same exterior finishing. You give up some linear length but gain a loft for smaller items. This model is ideal for DIYers who want a complete floor and additional storage tiers. It suits those who prioritize vertical organization and included features over maximum ground-level footprint. The compact size makes it suitable for yards where a full 12x20 shed is too large.

Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed

The Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed matches the original's footprint dimensions closely, at 157 by 243 inches. It includes a floor, which the original does not. The height is 119 inches, slightly lower than the original's 126 inches. The brown finish is included, eliminating the need for painting. This model offers a similar large storage capacity with a pre-finished exterior. You save time on painting but lose a few inches of vertical clearance. It is best for users who want a ready-to-use floor and a finished look. The compact width and length are nearly identical to the original. It is a practical alternative for those who prefer a completed exterior finish over the raw wood option.

ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed

The ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wooden Storage Shed is much longer, measuring 157 by 295 inches. It includes a floor, unlike the original. The height is 121 inches, slightly lower than the original's 126 inches. This extended length provides significantly more linear storage space for long equipment like ATVs. You gain over four feet of extra length but lose a bit of vertical clearance. The unpainted wood requires the same finishing work. This model is ideal for buyers who need maximum drive-in length for large machinery. It suits those who prioritize extensive horizontal space over height. The wider footprint may require more yard space, but it offers superior storage capacity for bulky items.

ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed

The ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Storage Shed is narrower, with a width of 136 inches compared to the original's 160 inches. It includes a floor, which the original lacks. The height is 120 inches, slightly lower than the original's 126 inches. The length is 258 inches, nearly matching the original's 257 inches. This model prioritizes vertical storage in a narrower footprint. You sacrifice width for a complete floor and similar length. It is best for users who need tall walls for vertical organization but have limited yard width. The unpainted wood requires the same finishing. It offers a compact alternative that still provides ample length for storing long items while saving space on the sides.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed

Best for: housing tractors and ATVs on concrete slabs

Material

Wood

Footprint Size

12 x 20 ft

Door Type

8 ft. wide double doors

Assembly

Pre-cut components, DIY assembly

Features

Two windows, 7 ft. high side walls

Recommended Use

Large lawn tractors, ATVs

View on Amazon: Handy Home Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed

The Handy Home Products Cedarhill provides a 12x20-foot wood structure with 7-foot side walls and 8-foot-wide double doors. Two built-in windows supply natural daylight and ventilation. The pre-cut components arrive unpainted without flooring, shingles, or paint. This shed suits you if you plan to pour a concrete slab and house large lawn tractors or ATVs.

Pros

• Wide 8-foot double doors accommodate tractors and ATVs
• Tall 7-foot side walls provide vertical storage clearance
• Two integrated windows supply natural light and ventilation
• Pre-cut wood components ready for DIY assembly

Cons

• Floor kit is not included
• Roofing shingles are not supplied
• Exterior paint is not included

Good fit if

• You plan to install your shed on an existing concrete slab or custom foundation.
• You need an 8-foot door opening to park large riding mowers or ATVs.
• You want built-in windows to provide interior lighting and ventilation.

Skip if

• You want a complete package that includes floor framing and decking.
• You prefer a kit that already includes shingles and exterior paint.

Verdict: Handy Home Products Cedarhill 12x20 Wood Shed is built for property owners who want drive-in storage for large equipment on a custom concrete foundation. Its wide double doors and tall side walls offer ample clearance, provided you supply your own floor, shingles, and paint.

2 Best premium

Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop

Best for: Storage of large lawn equipment and tools

Material

LP SmartSide siding, 2x4 wood framing

Footprint Size

12x18 ft

Capacity

216 sq. ft. interior

Door Type

Double doors, 60 in. W x 72 in. H

Frame Material

2x4 wood framing

Interior Dimensions

144 in. W x 216 in. L x 107 in. H

View on Amazon: Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Wood Workshop

This 12x18 ft shed offers 216 sq. ft. of interior space with 6 ft. sidewalls. It features 2x4 wood framing and LP SmartSide siding for durability. The unit includes a treated wood floor and operable windows for natural light. Large 60 x 72 inch double doors allow easy access for lawn equipment and tools. It is a solid DIY option for those needing ample storage.

Pros

• 216 sq. ft. interior capacity
• 60 in. W x 72 in. H double doors
• Includes treated 2x4 wood floor
• Operable windows for natural light
• LP SmartSide siding with 50-year warranty

Cons

• Smaller footprint than 12x20 alternatives
• Requires assembly and separate paint
• Heavy at 1971 pounds

Good fit if

• You need 216 sq. ft. of storage space
• You want a pre-built wood floor
• You prefer operable windows for ventilation

Skip if

• You require a 12x20 ft footprint
• You need a fully pre-assembled unit
• You want a shed that is pre-painted

Verdict: Little Cottage Co. 12x18 Value Workshop Shed provides a sturdy, well-lit workspace for tools and equipment, though its 12x18 size is slightly smaller than the 12x20 standard.

3 Also great

ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed

Best for: smaller yards needing a complete floor

Material

Treated engineered wood siding

Footprint Size

12x10 ft

Frame Material

2 x 4 framing, 24 in. on-center studs

Assembly

Pre-cut wood kit; 2+ adults; 8 hours

Recommended Use

Customizable wooden shed

Features

Floor

View on Amazon: ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed

This 12x10 ft wooden storage shed features a complete floor system and three operational windows with screens. The 2x4 framing supports wind up to 115 mph and snow loads up to 23 psf. You get double doors plus a service door for flexible access. The treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed and ready for your chosen paint and shingles. It requires assembly by two adults in about eight hours.

Pros

• Complete floor system included
• Three operational windows with screens
• Wind resistance up to 115 mph
• Snow load capacity of 23 psf

Cons

• Smaller 12x10 ft footprint than the 12x20 ft alternatives
• Paint and roof shingles are sold separately
• Heavy at 1600 pounds

Good fit if

• You need a smaller footprint than 12x20 ft
• You want a complete floor system included
• You plan to customize the exterior finish

Skip if

• You require a 12x20 ft storage space
• You want a fully assembled unit without painting
• You need a larger 12x24 ft option

Verdict: ShedMaster Meadowview 12x10 Wooden Shed is a compact, sturdy option for those who need less floor space but still want a complete floor and strong wind resistance. It fits buyers who prioritize customization and structural integrity over maximum storage volume.

4 Best budget

ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed

Best for: DIYers wanting a floor and loft in a smaller size

Material

Treated engineered wood

Footprint Size

12x16 ft

Door Type

64 in pre-hung double doors

Frame Material

Heavy-duty wood structure

Assembly

2 adults, 24 hours, intermediate skill

Features

Storage loft, window, wood floor kit

View on Amazon: ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Shed

The ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 is a DIY wooden storage shed with a floor kit. It measures 146 inches wide and 137 inches high. The unit includes a storage loft and a window for natural light. Pre-hung double doors are 64 inches wide. Treated engineered wood siding is factory-primed. You can customize the finish with paint and shingles sold separately. Assembly takes about 24 hours with two adults.

Pros

• Includes complete wood floor system
• Features a storage loft for extra space
• 64-inch pre-hung double doors for wide access
• Factory-primed siding ready for custom paint
• Window provides natural interior light

Cons

• Smaller footprint than the 12x20 models on this list
• Paint and shingles are sold separately
• Requires 24 hours of assembly time

Good fit if

• You need a floor system included in the kit
• You want a loft for additional storage
• You prefer to customize the exterior finish yourself

Skip if

• You require a 12x20 footprint
• You want a fully finished exterior without extra purchases
• You need a pre-assembled unit

Verdict: ShedMaster Westfield 12x16 Wooden Storage Shed fits buyers who want a floor and loft but can accept a smaller 12x16 size. It suits those willing to spend time on assembly and painting.

5 Also great

Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed

Best for: Storing tall ladders and gardening tools

Material

Wood

Footprint Size

12x20 ft

Roof Style

9 ft 11 in peak height

Features

7 ft tall side walls

Recommended Use

Ladders, rakes, shovels

Color

Brown

View on Amazon: Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wood Shed

The Handy Home Astoria 12x20 is a do-it-yourself wooden storage shed designed for large tool and equipment storage. It features 7-foot side walls and a 9-foot 11-inch peak height, allowing you to store tall items like ladders and rakes. The unit includes extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors for easy access. Note that the floor kit is not included, requiring you to prepare a custom foundation.

Pros

• 7-foot tall side walls for vertical storage
• 9-foot 11-inch peak height accommodates tall gear
• Extra-large 5-foot 4-inch wide doors
• Continuous galvanized steel hinges on doors

Cons

• Floor kit is not included
• Paint and shingles are sold separately
• Not available in Florida due to weather restrictions

Good fit if

• You need to store tall items like ladders
• You prefer a custom foundation like a cement pad
• You want wide doors for easy equipment access

Skip if

• You live in Florida
• You want a pre-built floor included
• You need a fully painted and shingled unit

Verdict: The Handy Home Astoria 12x20 Wooden Shed fits buyers who need maximum vertical clearance for tall tools and are ready to build their own floor and finish the exterior.

6 Also great

ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed

Best for: storing long equipment and ATVs

Material

Treated engineered wood siding

Footprint Size

12 x 24 ft

Frame Material

16 in. on-center wall studs

Assembly

Pre-cut wood kit, 2 adults, 32 hours

Roof Style

10 ft. overall height

Recommended Use

ATV units and large equipment

View on Amazon: ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wood Storage Shed

This DIY wooden storage shed offers a 12 by 24 foot footprint with 7 foot side walls and 10 foot overall height. It features treated engineered wood siding that is factory-primed for painting. The structure includes 8 foot double doors with a 64 by 70 inch opening for large equipment. You get 16 inch on-center wall studs for strong support. This kit requires assembly by two adults over approximately 32 hours.

Pros

• 12 by 24 foot footprint provides large storage capacity
• 7 foot side walls allow for vertical shelving
• 8 foot double doors accommodate ATVs and large gear
• 16 inch on-center wall studs ensure structural strength

Cons

• 32 hour assembly time is lengthy for DIYers
• Floor kit, paint, and roofing are not included
• No pre-installed floor panel in the base kit

Good fit if

• You need extra length for storing long items
• You want to customize the exterior finish yourself
• You have two people to help with assembly

Skip if

• You want a fully assembled structure delivered
• You need a floor included in the box
• You prefer a smaller 10 by 20 foot footprint

Verdict: ShedMaster Broadside 12x24 Wooden Storage Shed fits buyers needing maximum linear storage space for large equipment. Its extended 24 foot length and tall walls suit those planning custom finishes and extensive vertical organization.

7 Also great

ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed

Best for: Vertical storage needs in a 10x20 space

Footprint Size

10x20 ft

Frame Material

2x4 wood framing

Features

7 ft. side wall height, floor kit

Recommended Use

Long-handled tools, bulky items

Dimensions

258 × 136 × 120 inches

View on Amazon: ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Shed

The ShedMaster Expanse is a 10x20 ft DIY wooden storage shed with a floor kit. It features 7 ft side walls for tall tools and sturdy 2x4 wood framing. You get extra-wide double doors and a side entry door for access. The LP SmartSide siding is pre-primed for painting. This unit suits those needing vertical space and durable construction.

Pros

• 7 ft side wall height for tall items
• Includes floor kit for stable base
• Extra-wide 64 in double doors
• Sturdy 2x4 wood framing construction

Cons

• Smaller 10x20 footprint than 12x20 alternatives
• 32-hour assembly time required
• Paint and roofing sold separately

Good fit if

• You need extra vertical space for long-handled tools
• You want a pre-primed wooden structure to customize
• You prefer a smaller 10x20 footprint

Skip if

• You require a 12x20 or larger interior
• You want a fully assembled unit delivered
• You need paint or roofing included

Verdict: ShedMaster Expanse 10x20 Wooden Storage Shed fits users who prioritize tall walls and a included floor over maximum square footage. It is ideal for storing bulky items in a slightly narrower space.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions